date

19 June 1805 Evidence Introd
19 June 1805

Evidence

Introd

Ch. Procedure technical

''.9. Exceptions Pauper List

At the very earliest stage of the cause, at the very same stage in which the like effect would later place under the natural, and does actually take place under the waiting[?] summary mode /course/ of procedure, the defendant, and his prosecutor, and such witnesses or other witnesses of any, as happen to be at hand /forthcoming/, are introduced together into the presence of a Judge. Each accordingly, at that preparatory meeting called the examination each has the liberty of putting questions to each, the Judge to both or either, for the maxim which leaves it to the desire[?] of the defendant whether he will give an answer, does /is/ not in that stage at least, understood to destroy altogether, howsoever it may impede the liberty of questioning /putting questions/.

Moreover, by one means or other, indeed or rather to give the short account of it, by so simple a means as the forbearing to extend the art of making business to a case in which there is nothing to be got by making it, quick work, quick by comparison at least is made of the case of felonies: so quick, that instances have not been wanting, in which the three inquiries, (two of them it will be seen somewhat worse than useless) + which take place of course in prosecutions for felony, have been all compressed into the compass of one day. True it is, that notwithstanding this accidental /casual/ dispatch, the mean duration of a prosecution for felony is in the greater part of England 3 months; in some parts in which the suffering of the individual and the prompt execution of the law is in the eye of the law of less moment, six month. (a) But in these three months, and these six months, after deduction of those for which in favourable circumstances a part of a day is sufficient, nothing at all is done. + Of that sort of business, which in case of [...?] which instead of life, a few pounds or a few shillings were at stake is so unnecessary to be made, none is made here, because here, as before observed nothing is to be got by making it +2 about.

Securities

(a) These numbers are mathematically correct: as will be found by whoever considers that in some parts of England the Circuit Court is held but once a twelvemonth in most parts six months. In London and Middlesex, the months are reduced to weeks

+ laying out of the setting out of the account that corruption of mind and body and mind, which is not worth thinking about.

+2 So that Upon the whole [...?] if the time in which nothing /no business/ is done but the work of corruption is rather of the longest the time in which any business is done is short in this branch of technical procedure; viz: not many times as long as that which the business of the same case would have occupied in the natural mode.
Similar Items
  • Title: [[094-304v] 22 May 1806 Evidence]
    Description: [094-304v]

    22 May 1806

    Evidence

    '. 3 [...?]

    Why all this argumentation about a transcript? If it is not here now, why not produce it tomorrow? Why not produce the original at once? Such is the question /the difficulty/ that can scarce fail to present itself to a common [...?], especially in a case where it is seen that the original is in existence, and producible without difficulty.

    This is but one amidst a list of questions, all [...?] /difficulties and all [...?]/ with difficulties that will be continually presenting themselves to a man who sets out with [...?] notice that the ends of justice have been the real ends of judicature: who suffers himself to be led away by the supposition, that the forms /by which the procedure of [...?] is distinguished from that of [...?] Judges/ have been directed any of them to any better object, than the making two seats out of one.

    Tomorrow? Yes: tomorrow the original may be produced, should the want of its production chance to survive all the accidents with which it is beset, should it escape all the scares that have been laid for it. Tomorrow? - but on what to-morrow? a tomorrow which, if it comes at all, will come at the end of twelve months , or at the earliest six months time: and which, whenever it does come, will come loaded with "double double[?] toil and trouble", and above all with double fees. Think whether under these circumstances there be common sense in expecting /the expectation/ that the exertions of the supporters /zeal employed in the support/ of the transcript will be equally strenuous with that of the [...?] /whether the zeal of the champions who fight for double fees, will be equally [...?...?] spirited, and present an equal chance of success with that which has for its object the [...?] of the [...?] to single fees./

    The interest were made - to what end? amongst others /amongst other reasons/ , to make it worth men's while to knock causes on the head /down the hill/ by irrelevant questions of all sorts, and amongst others by questions about evidence: questions about evidence /-to what end-/ were started to take advantage of these interests. The delay was made to let in the business with its profit: the profit was let in /made/ by the help of delay.
  • Title: [20 Oct r 1807 Eldon's Bill]
    Description: 20 Oct r 1807

    Eldon's Bill

    '.4. (1) ( dispatch of business during the time of Session)

    Dispatch of business - the object thus placed in close contact with the limitative clause, the purpose of which if it has any is to counteract it as the object that calls forth this note.

    Dispatch of business the declared object and only /sole/ declared object of this section - dispatch of business the declared object and only declared object of the whole Bill - and /now that for/ the first time any application is made of it close in contact with it is stuck on a clause that has no other effect than to limit /obstruct/ it: to limit it, and to what use /good purpose/ let any one imagine.

    (The time of Session is but /lasts but for/ six months out of the twelve: six other months are /composes/ the time allotted to the reign and triumph of injustice.

    Denial of justice, a general /generally extensive/ and regularly established denial of justice the duration of it extending to several whole years - a denial of justice confessed by the diners [...?] and loudly complained of /proclaimed/ by /on the part of/ the sufferers being the grievance and dispatch of business the appropriate remedy for the grievance being the professed object, what is the first care? not too much should be done for the attainment of it.

    "The time of Session" - the time allotted for justice - lasts but six months out of the twelve: six other months compose the time allotted to the reign and triumph of injustice.

    Such is not mans care when /where/ justice is really an /the/ object. Such was not the care of Edward the 3 d's Parliament +, when traders being the class of suitors in consideration - (all traders without exception or limitation, and not foreign traders only, as the learned and astute editors of the Statute Book with its marginal contents would have it thought) the will of Parliament was declared that right should be done not only day by day, but hour by hour... so that the /those/ suitors should not by malice be deprived of a sufficiently speedy remedy.

    +27 E.3 p.2.c.19. A o 1353

    (for while this object was assigned to the proposed "new arrangements none at all was assigned to the proposed regulations, "the regulations touching appeals")
  • Title: [13 June 1804 Procedures (3)]
    Description: 13 June 1804

    Procedures (3)

    Ch Basis

    Domestic

    In the technical forms /plans/ of procedure, witnesses, and especially /but mere [...?]/ those who from their situation are best acquainted or the only persons that have been at all acquainted with what has happened, are refused a hearing /to be heard/ find the doors of the Court sht against them, upon an endless variety /a variety/ of pretences. - Why? because examination of a suspicious /suspected/ /extraction of the truth out of the lips of an unwillingness[?]/ witness requires because the extraction /suspension[?]/ of unwilling evidence, and the weighing of contradictory evidence requires talent as well as industry /labour/ - and refusal to bear it requires neither.

    A course which might be dispatched in an hour were the parties brought face to face in the presence of the Judge and thus examined vivâ voce is spun out for months or years: persons without number being employed all the while in scribbling papers without end: /+the Judge under whose order every thing is supposed to be done, either hearing nothing at all of /about/ the business the whole time /from beginning to end/, or not taking it up till all this labour has been thrown away /wasted on it/. Why? because for every word thus scribbled, one man or another is paid at enormous rates, every man connected in some way /character/ or other /by some tie or other of interest or sympathy/ - dependance[/] community of profit, personal intimacy professional per[?] [...?] at least with the Judge with those by whose power had not the wish been wanting, the abuse might have been from the first prevented, or at one time or[?] other[?] done away. even the Judge himself commonly a valuable property to no small amount in the shape of hard money, in every useless vexation either neglected by his orders, or nursed /cherished[?] [...?] [...?]/ by his connivance.