26 May 1804

Evidence

Ch Extraction

§ 5 Engl. Law

§ 5. English law.

The English law, how happy soever it may have bee in the choice it has made /invention it has displayed/ of coercive processes applicable to this purpose, is still more conspicuously /manifestly/ unhappy in the application it has made of them. The most coercive and only effectual process it employs may without any misapplication of terms /abuse of words/, be stated torture, adding to distinguish it from the drastic violently and promptly operating processess elsewhere understood by /commonly designated by/ that name, slow torture. The class of persons it is applied to are not criminals nor delinquents or persons labouring under so much as a suspicion of delinquency - but honest men /men without reproach/ - nor yet honest men /men of that description/ taken at random but silent men - the good men and true of whom the Jury is composed. The compliance - the sort of service for the extraction of which it is applied to men thus honourably distinguished, is that sort of service which on the part of each man to whom the torture is applied, consists in concurring in his quality of the Judge in /with/ a decision which to him appears false and injurious /unjust/, as that in

violation of an oath which he has just been forced to take:

torture applied to a person acting in the character of the [074-426/2]

Judge, for the purpose of compelling him to do injustice aggravated by perjury.

In practice, by the punishment /infliction/ terrible in description, no actual suffering to any considerable amount is ever produced: why? because of the irresistible severity of it. For the offence which he is thus forced /promted/ [...?] to the commission of to commit - the offence against justice - compleat impunity is secured to him: from the injury and death to which if he did not committ the offence he would be consigned, there is no escape.

Of this reason [?] of tyranny and corruption, what is the object if it has any? / / Falshood, inexpressibly everlastingly delicious falshood. To produce a false appearance of unanimity, applicable in the way of argument, to a variety of deceitful purposes.
Similar Items
  • Title: [1820. Octr. 12 Spanish liberticide measures]
    Description: 1820. Octr. 12 Spanish liberticide measures. 15 §. 2. I. Press violation

    Reasons against libel laws

    4. If such things were allowed, no honest no honourable no honest man no man who

    had any regard for his honour for his reputation, would be found to take upon

    himself any such situation: and the consequence is that all such situations

    would fall into the hands of men who had neither honour nor honesty, and thus

    the country would be involved in certain and compleat destruction. So says the

    argument

    But of all this the contrary has been shewn already. Honest or dishonest,

    honourable or dishonourable, every man will be ready to take upon himself any

    /and to continue to occupy and to maintain himself a/ situation the evil of

    which is outweighed by the good. In England to a vast extent so prodigious is

    this preponderance, that to obtain these situations there is nothing so

    dishonourable that to obtain them men of all ranks from the highest to the

    lowest are not ready and eager to do, and do accordingly and are not the less

    stiled not only honest but honourable. Falshood solemn and deliberate falshood

    has been shewn to be a necessary step, perjury – perjury acknowledged by

    themselves to be such a commonly employed step /among the most frequent steps/

    to the most richly endowed, the most powerful and most highly dignified

    situations in the Ecclesiastical and self-stiled religious establishment. In

    England no situation is in want of candidates: numerous and eager candidates: of

    whom in the instance of each such situation one /in each vacancy/ is succesful

    and when thus admitted ask any one of them, whether with a few accidental

    exceptions, of which his case does not form one, they are not, all of them

    honest and honourable. But in England though no such things as the things in

    question have ever been allowed allowed by law, yet such in that part of the law

    is the happy and useful weakness, so happily applied in that instance is the

    anarchy or the mixture of anarchy and tyranny of which so large a portion of the

    whole mass of law in that country is composed that the reputations of men in

    office are little less exposed to the sort of impuations of the sort in question

    than if they were allowed: and accordingly, and in the highest and most richly

    endowed and most powerful situations men may be seen wallowing and triumphing in

    profligacy, […?] in infamy, and yet as fondly attached to and as firmly fixt in

    their respective situations as if virtue in them were consummate.

    Commanders of torture spectators of torture encouragers and promoters of torture

    by refusing to hear and preventing the disclosure of it

    Commanders of the murder of the innocent rewarders of the murder of the innocent,

    commanders of torture, spectators of torture, forgers /fabricators/ of rules of

    pretended law to justify the murder of the innocent
  • Title: [26 May 1804 Evidence Ch. Extraction]
    Description: 26 May 1804

    Evidence

    Ch. Extraction

    § Engl. Law

    In the case of a delinquent /delinquency/ - of an individual presumed or suspected of delinquency, all this rigour is laid aside. The law knows /admitts/ of no other infliction in the character of a compulsive process, the law admitts of no other infliction, than simple imprisonment. What is the consequence? that in many cases a long protracted course of suffering is produced - a long remainder[?] of life filled not infrequently with bitterness, and the object in view not compassed / / after all - : the quantity of suffering augmented, and the whole of it thrown away.

    Many a dishonest debtor in whom the juryman's torture would have produced immediate compliance, carries the fruits of this dishonesty with him to prison, and there consumes them, in defiance of his injured and impoverished creditors.

    In the case of bankruptcy, i.e. commercial insolvency non-responsion and false-responsion is /are/ indeed as far as concerns the concealment of effects /assets/ applicable in satisfaction of debts, made punishable and punishable with death; but even here the distant and eludible punishment is preferred to the unelludible and instant compulsory infliction; and in cases of non-commercial insolvency, and in all other cases in which evidence is supposed to be extracted

    simple imprisonment and that alone is applied, and is the only [074-427/2]

    infliction applicable. This infliction is indeed susceptible of prodigious variation, under the same name variable upon a prodigiously extensive scale: depending upon the localities of the prison - the accommodations afforded by the prison, and the exterior appendages /territory/ annexed to it: but the variations depend upon accident, are the result /product/ not of justice /wisdom/ but of negligence and in practice are not applied, nor indeed capable of being applied with uniformity to this purpose.
  • Title: [23. Aug. 1812 Evidence Introd]
    Description: 23. Aug. 1812

    Evidence Introd

    Introd

    Ch. 15 Preappointed Offices

    '. Obstacles

    False Muster

    [...?] or far as to a man in his [...?] any thing other than undistorted repose can be an object

    '. Swindling how sanctioned in military officers by lawyer-led legislators - False musters

    Among military men it continues still a point of honour if not to abstain from lying, at any rate not to endure the imputation of it. To the man of law, not speak of the priest it was no small object, to corrupt the morals of the military man and plant in his mind if possible the love of falshood, at any rate an indifference to truth.

    In the military profession [...?] of the point of honour, a practice and craft of applying falshood in the character of an instrument for the extraction of sinister profit. Money was received on false pretences the pretence was the existence of a certain number of men in a body of troops in which no such men were to be found. False musters were the denomination by which depredation in this shape had come to be designated

    In the purpose of a cloak as usual, some of the money thus diverted had been applied to a public purpose. The purpose having been found useful, advantage was taken of this circumstance by the lovers of fraud, and instead of employing honest means they lent the sanction of government to these dishonest ones: as if government had no better means of getting money than by encouraging one set of its servants to turn swindlers tell lies, and in this way pilfer it from another. from their public servants in another office by setting one part of its servants to steal it from another.

    A sanction was accordingly given to it, by the hand of the legislator? in what form? considering by what sort of hands the legislator is in this country habitually and unavoidably led, the form may be imagined.

    The sanction was applied - not to the form /purpose/ only but to the instrument. the fraud itself was legalised.

    Extracts from [...?] Index to the Statutes, with Soldiers

    44. Penalties on persons making false certificates to excuse from Musters

    IV G.3.C.3. '.10.

    45. And [...?] Offices making false musters, IV G.3.C.3. '.11, 21.

    48. Fictitious names where allowed in a muster, G.3.c.3 C.3. '.12 This was the Mutiny Act of the year in which this Index was printed Mutiny Act and Index.