date

6 July 1811 29 V ad Juperbriam Fallacies
6 July 1811 29 V ad Juperbriam

Fallacies Ch. | | Posterity Chainers

22 or 10 or 3

| | Due and plausible, when

1 Contract

Note that in this case a further observation is that at all times whatsoever privileges or advantages (be the name employed what it may) the whole community is understood to be capable of receiving without prejudice to its own happiness /itself/ at the hands of the governing part of it those it ought at all times it ought to be /have/ in possession of. In this case therefore, if of the proposed change the effect be suppose to be that of giving increase the utmost practicable increase to the aggregate happiness of the community as above, compensation is thereby made nor is there either need of a room for compensation in any other Shape
Similar Items
  • Title: [3 July 1811 8 V ad Juperbriam Fallacies]
    Description: 3 July 1811 8 V ad Juperbriam

    Fallacies Ch | | Posterity-Chainers

    4 4

    2. Exposition continued

    Occasions parties

    6. The 5\T thT\ case presents two or more sovereignties concerned: sovereignties not the less distinct though it should happen to one and the same person, in the character of principal member - or otherwise, to have a part in each of them.
  • Title: [3 July 1811 6 V ad Juperbriam Fallacies]
    Description: 3 July 1811 6 V ad Juperbriam

    Fallacies Ch. 1. Posterity-chainers

    2 2

    2. Exposition continued

    Occasions parties

    Or[?] As to the occasions on which the imposition of such restrictions have been or seems capable of being /likely to be/ attempted they seem comprizable under the following list

    1. The establishment of any law by the sovereign with the concurrence of all persons and bodies of persons having part in the sovereignty /sovereign power/ at the time

    2. /4/ In case of a compound sovereignty /composite sovereign body/ a New arrangement of its component powers amongst the members.

    3. /2/ Concession made of privileges by the sovereignty or a principal member having power from the whole to the subjects in general.

    4. /3/ Concession made as above to a particular subject or class of subjects.

    5. Incorporative Union whereby two states having or not having one common head are by agreement put under one sovereignty.

    6. Formation of a government, and thence of a sovereignty by individuals coming together in a state of independences.
  • Title: [6 July 1811 30 V. ad Juperbriam Fallacies]
    Description: 6 July 1811 30 V. ad Juperbriam

    Fallacies Ch. 1

    23 or 17 or 4

    | | Demand plausible whether

    2. Grant of privilege

    2. Grant of privilege from the sovereignty to a portion of the community in the character of subjects.

    If by /in/ the grant here in question the affect foreseen at the time was the making any clear defalcation from the aggregate happiness of the community as above, it ought not at that time to have been made.

    On the other hand /Nor on the other hand /in the contrary case// as little ought an

    And /Moreover/ on the other hand as to any proposed change unless from or on occasion of it a clear addition in some shape or other to the /that/ aggregate mass be the sufficiently probable result the change itself, consisting in the abolition of the contract or some alteration made in the effect of it, ought not to have been made. And by the supposition that portion of the community which had been a party to the contract being as much a portion, and the as large a portion of the community as any other composed of equal numbers, the advantage supposed to accrue to the whole community taken in the aggregate could not accrue to it but by the further supposition that for any disadvantage resulting to such contracting portion adequate compensation has been made.

    Under this head are included all those more particular cases which exhibit the sovereignty in the act of contracting with this or that individual or assemblage of individuals, for money or money's worth to be supplied or service in this or that other shape rendered, on the other.