date

1819 Aug. 17 Fallacies 1 Forms
1819 Aug. 17

Fallacies 1 Forms

[4 Forms.]

Forms. Another very convenient cloak for abuse and misgovernment - for foul spots of all sorts and sizes - is presented by the word forms - by the nebulosity of the word forms. /: a very paragon of nebulosity./

By forms are meant either operations of government or instruments of government meaning written instruments, produced by correspondent operations: the living instruments of government - the members of the appropriate part of the Official Establishment being, in both cases, the operators.

Now among these operations, productive or not /some productive, some not/ of corresponent instruments, there have doubtless been some good: but moreover, unless the official persons in question have been absolutely infllible and impeccable, some bad. It is required to reconcile men to the bad: to cause them to be regarded as good: this is the problem, how shall this problem /it/ be solved?

Tale the individual operattion itself, and apply laud[?] to it, the danger is that the laud will not stick; and the more palpably undeserving of laud the operations is - in other words the more palpably deserving of reproach in a word the more palpably mischevious - the greater the difficulty of making /getting/ it to stick.
Similar Items
  • Title: [1819 Aug. 15 9 Fallacies Ch | | Logical]
    Description: 1819 Aug. 15 9

    Fallacies Ch | | Logical Highfliers

    3

    In all these several cases two objects may be distinguished: one which may be termed the foul spot; namely, according to the extent of it, abuse in this or that particular shape, or the whole system of abuse: the other, the cloak: the cloudy appellative employed as a cloak or cover for the abuse.

    As to the foul spot it may be determinate and thence apparent, or indeterminate, and thence unapparent and undistinguishable.

    So accordingly, on the other hand the cloak may be either a general or a special one: a general one, applying to abuse in all its forms; a special one, applying to abuse in this or that particular form, more particularly or even exclusively with reference to all others.

    For example, turn to the above list. For cloaks, you will see, the words Government, Law, Constitution (meaning the English Constitution) English Institutions, Forms, Order, alias Good Order and Social Order, Religion. Among the works of Government are all the good arrangements that can be seen any where established; as /so/ likewise /and along[?] with them/ all the bad ones. By the undiscriminating eulogy bestowed on Government, the word Government is made or endeavoured to be made, to serve as a cloak to the bad ones: and no sooner does a man bring to view any of the badness of any of the bad ones, than he becomes an enemy to Government.

    Among the works of Law in like manner are all the good laws that can be seen any where established, so likewise all the bad ones: here then are laws another cloak for the bad ones: and another of the sacred things to which the reformist is an enemy.
  • Title: [[**104-060**] 1819 Aug. 8 Fallacies]
    Description: [**104-060**]

    1819 Aug. 8

    Fallacies 7

    4. Sham-distinguisher's device/

    This is the converse of the Lumping-Classifiers device. For the purpose of finding a justification for suppressing the suppression of some course of action which upon the whole has more of usefulness than mischeviousness in it, he presents it to you as distinugishable into two courses, one more useful than mischevious, another more mischevious than useful. Admitt this, he then proceeds in his endeavours to suppress the whole, telling you it is only to the mischevious part that his intention and endeavours are directed.

    Take for example the liberty of examining into the usefulness or mischeviousness of the several arrangements included under the name of Law, Government, Constitution, &c as above, and the operations performed by the several functionaries in the exercise of their several functions. The liberrty of this examination he will acknowledge to be indisputably necessary to good government: but thou this liberty must be unaccompanied with licentiousness: for licentiousness is as /no less/ hostile to the end in view as /than/ liberty is friendly to it. Whereas between liberty and licentiousness - between the things themselves there is no real distinction: where a mans meaning /[...?]/ is to be considered as friendly to this liberty, liberty is the denomination he employs: where he is /can not but be/ seen to act seen[?] to be in actual hostility hostility disposed towards it licentiousness is the term he employs in speaking of it.
  • Title: [1 May 1811 Hints[?] (or Fallacies]
    Description: 1 May 1811

    Hints[?] (or Fallacies) (or Necessity of Parl. Reform)

    1.II. Arbitrary Patronage

    Ch. 4. Uses of Controul

    So far as depends upon moral aptitude sole means (in legislature's hands) of

    securing good management, and preventing official (or other) transgression,

    connecting officer's personal with his public interest: so managing; thrust[?]

    the since[?] [...?] of conduct thus conducive to his public shall d\ToT\ to his

    personal. Thus alone[?] more adequate motives

    Public man to whom probity i.e. sincerity is wanting, or intelligence to

    arranagements of the wbove tendency, such to entpolitate[?] preachments

    Bad effects of such preachments - 1. Putting end[?], the only true remedy: 2. By

    exaggeration raising in the scale of disrepute and infamy the least mischevious

    transgressions to a level with the most mischevious - and thus encouraging the

    most mischevious where they are the most profitable. 3. Representing them[?],

    most and least mischevious together as so odious so justly odious that not the

    least danger of falling into any them[?], can be imputed to using person

    individually intense[?], nor if the situation be high to any person filling that

    situation: thus representing a improbable and thence not worth guarding against

    that which in truth is universal, or marly[?] so.