date

1819 May 25 A. Defence of Ballot
1819 May 25 A.

Defence of Ballot – III. against B

Objection 1. Ought ergo will

1

After all this argumentation /mass of argument/ In a mass of argument thus celebrated, /In all this/ /the fruit of so much labour /industry/ and that labour /industry/ produced /set to work/ by so strong an interest/ one thing there is that gives /affords/ me real satisfaction: This is /and this/ the not seeing any use made of the two objections neither of which /which neither of them/ ever presented themselves to my eyes or ears without bringing with it real uneasiness: uneasiness produced certainly /assuredly/ not by the idea /sense/ /perception/ of this strength, but by the idea of their /view of their extreme/ weakness

Considering the pertinacity with which I have seen them clung to by those men from whom I should have expected better things, and from whom on other subjects belonging to the field of reform I have seen and heard so much better things, I am almost ashamed to mention them.

1. One consists in this argument. Men ought to give out /forth/ their votes in the finest[?] manner: therefore so they will. Men ought not to go afraid to make their votes known: therefore they will not.

Oh rare logic! all men ought always to do what they ought: therefore so they always will.

Oh rare logic! If this /it/ be indeed conclusive, what a land is this we live in? what a race /species is this we belong to? The conclusion is it a just /legitimate/ one? Reformists may save their labour This logic will do every thing. Try it upon both Houses, what is /comes to/ the same thing try it upon Ministers who ever they are: or to go to the root and do every thing at a stroke, try it upon the Monarch, whoever he is. If this reasoning be legitimate, all Parliamentary reform, reform in every shape is needless. Try it upon the whole race, Utopia is realised. {Try it /Apply it/ upon all sinners, from sinners they become /start up/ saints: original sin is wasted away.}

This logic is no dream: at this moment my eyes have it in black and white: my ears have over and over again been assaulted /grated/ by it. +

In a letter /present letter to myself/ I see this passage: I would not for a good deal though he were to command me I would for a good deal betray the author’s name.

☞ Quere 25 May 1819 whether to add a denial of the antecedent?

+ ☞ Quote Northmoors[?] letter
Similar Items
  • Title: [1819 May 30 Defence of | | Ballot]
    Description: 1819 May 30

    Defence of | | Ballot

    Objection 1. Ought ergo will

    3

    They ought? the subject many – they /the men of low degree/ ought to sacrifice themselves? Say rather he ought not – the man of the ruling few – ought not thus to call for – thus to compel – the sacrifice.
  • Title: [1818 Feb y 2 Not Paul III.]
    Description: 1818 Feb y 2

    Not Paul

    III. Doctrine

    Ch. Motives to Doctrine

    Asceticism II. Bed

    I. Ordinary

    1. Celibacy

    Good for a man not to touch a woman? as observes somebody—and stupid indeed must he

    have been to whom the observation has not presented itself—then how is the race of

    the faithful—and should the religion of Jesus spread as it was his declared intention

    /design/ it should spread how is the race of mankind to be preserved from extinction?

    for it is not to preachers alone—it is to all his converts at Corinth without

    distinction that this recommendation is addressed. The industry /anxiety/ of

    defenders may apply as many restrictions to as great an extent as they please: but to

    whatsoever extent the restriction is applied by them the restriction will be all of

    it of their own applying /doing/, none of it of Paul’s. being /no such thing being/

    applied by Paul himself.

    How is the race of mankind to be preserved from extinction? a question by which some

    men might feel themselves a little /thus capable of perplexing some men/, but Paul

    has his answer ready. Marry ever so (says he) the race of men will not be preserved

    from extinction: not so much as to the end of the present generation: for before that

    period there will be an end of this wicked world /the world/ and of the present

    generation along with it. On the present occasion in the present Epistle only in the

    way of allusion is mention made of this catastrophe. But in one of his two short

    Epistles to his Thessalonians, the proximity of it /as above/ /as hath been or will

    be seen†/ is directly announced. Only in his addresses to his disciples of /in/ that

    region is any such precision and particularity to be found. But in this present

    Epistle of his to his Corinthians, indications of the assurances they can /could/ not

    but have already received from him—indications too plain to be misunderstood will now

    be seen.

    † Ch. Paul’s Character. §. Falsified predictions.

    I. Cor. ix. 25. Now concerning virgins (says /continues/

    he), I have no commandment of the Lord: candid indeed this: but of this candour the

    cause may be seen in that contempt of asceticism the negative proofs of which have

    reached these our times and of which the positive proofs it may well be imagined were

    /were in those days/ matters of notoriety to all who had heard any thing of the

    history of Jesus.†

    † See Ch. In Jesus no asceticism.
  • Title: [1819 May 25 Defence of | | Ballot]
    Description: 1819 May 25

    Defence of | | Ballot

    Caucussing 1

    2. beneficial

    11

    Thus then to an impartial /unbiassed/ judgment /eye/ out of the reach of all those causes of delusion which are produced by acquaintance more or less particular with individuals

    viewing the men only as men, sufficient cause, it is believed will appear for the conclusion that in the situation in question bribery if ever it has place is extremely rare the number of in if there be any instances at all in which bribery in any shape has place the number of them is extremely small, and that even in those instances, be they ever so numerous, no sensible evil is among the results of it.

    {Be the situation what it may, suppose a man fit for it, money given for it whether by himself or by a friend for him does not divest him of those endowments by which he was /his appropriate aptitude is/ constituted fit.}