10 Oct. 1815

Jug. True

Ch. 71 Blind and dumb Devil

Time per omnes hos[?] unparticularized: reported Luke XI. 14 next after the conversation about the one thing needful in Martha’s house Luke X 38

Place at or near Jerusalem as appears by the antecedent conversations with the Pharisees &c. without any intervening report of migration

Contradiction – Per Luke a devil cast out and he only dumb. Per Matt. a man healed who being possessed by a devil was blind and dumb

Then in both occurs the conversation as per next chapter of this

In Mark the conversation but without mention of the miracle.

Immediately before the conversation in Mark instead of the account of the miracle it is said ‘his friends … went out to lay hold on him for they said he is beside himself

Contradictory as the accounts are the incident must be one and the same: the conversation being so exactly the same. It can not be that on occasion there was a dumb devil cast out, on another a blind and dumb man whose blindness and dumbness were caused by his being possessed by the devil cured by the casting out of the devil, and on a third occasion this same conversation held without any miracle to introduce it. Mark had he never heard of the miracle in either shape? did he not give credit to it? or did he regard it as not worth mentioning?

Ch. 71.

Near Jerusalem a dumb devil cast out, or a man who, being possessed by a devil, was blind and dumb, healed.

Luke XI. 14. Matt. XII. 22. Mark silent. John silent.
Similar Items
  • Title: [12 Sept. 1815 Jug True Ch.]
    Description: 12 Sept. 1815

    Jug True

    Ch. 72 Devils by Beelzebub

    Time not ascertainable. In Luke XI Matt. XII & Mark III in all three a different time. In Luke it comes next after the Lord’s Prayer. Place in Luke not specified – nor in Matthew – Nor in Mark In Matt. XII 22 it comes next after the healing the man with the withered hand on the Sabbath. In Mark III. 19. it also comes next after the nomination of the twelve which is after the healing of the withered hand, with an interval between during which multitudes flocking to get into a ship i.e. boat to be clear of them as he was preaching to them.

    Per Mark no miracle on this occasion. Per Luke a dumb devil cast out. Per Matthew, a blind and dumb devil

    Note it is while he is casting out this devil that in Luke some are calling on him for a sign. This then was no sign. Why? because (per Jesus) their sons cast out Devils too.

    Blasphemy against the Holy Ghost imputing these miracles to Beelzebub.

    Nonsensicalness of the dry places parable.} Not with me against me – in direct contradiction to the same Luke but two chapters before. Luke IX. 50

    Luke’s brief mention of the Holy Ghost comes at a later period.

    Ch. 72

    Conversation on the question by whom he cast out devils whether by Beelzebub or the Holy Ghost – Sin against the Holy Ghost unpardonable. Occasion not ascertainable – three different occasions mentioned by the three reporting Evangelists. Inexplicable parable about the dispossessed man walking in dry places, and receiving seven devils instead of the one. On hearing it A woman breaks out into benedictions.

    As to the dumb devil cast out Luke XI. 14. As to the blind and dumb devil Matt. XII. 22. 23. John silent

    As to the conversation about Beelzebub Luke XI 15 to 23. Matt. XII 24 to 30. Mark III. 22 to 27. John silent

    As to the Sin against the Holy Ghost Luke XII. 10 Matt. XII 31 to 37. Mark III. 28. 29. 30. John silent

    As to the unclean spirit in the dry places Luke XI. 24 to 26. Matt. XII. 43 to 45.

    As to woman’s benedictions Luke XI. 27. 28.
  • Title: [14 Sept. 1815 Jug True Chapters]
    Description: 14 Sept. 1815

    Jug True

    Chapters Titles of

    Ch. 68

    Parable of the good Samaritan. From neighbours as in the Jewish law the description of the objects of love limited to benefactors.

    Luke X. 25 to 37.

    Math. silent. Mark silent. John silent.

    Ch. 69

    At Simon Peters house at Bethany, John XI 1. Martha rebuked for officiousness – Mary for choosing ‘the thing needful’, mentioned as a model.

    Luke X. 38 to 42

    Math. silent

    Mark silent John silent

    Ch. 70

    In answer to the request of a prayer to serve as a model, the Lords prayer delivered. Forgiveness of offences inculcated – Importunity recommended by a parable – promise that whatever asked shall be granted.

    Luke XI. 1 to 13.

    Math. VI. 5 to 15 VII. 7 to 11. Mark silent. John silent.

    Ch. 71

    Near Jerusalem, a dumb devil cast out, or a man who being possessed by a devil was blind and dumb, healed.

    Luke XI. 14. Matt. XII. 22. Mark silent. John silent.

    Ch. 72

    conversation on the question by whom he cast out devils whether by Belzebub or the Holy Ghost. Sin against the Holy Ghost unpardonable – occasion not ascertainable – three different occasions mentioned by the three reporting evangelists. Inexplicable parable concerning the possessed man walking in dry places, and receiving seven devils instead of the one. on hearing it a woman breaks out into benedictions. As to the dumb devil cast out Luke XI .14. As to the blind and dumb devil Math. XII 22, 23. John silent As to the conversation about Belzebub Luke XI. 15 to 23. Math. XII. 24 to 30. Mark III 19 to 27. John silent.

    As to the sin against the Holy Ghost – Luke XII. 10. Math. XII. 31 to 37. Mark III 28 to 30. John silent.

    As to the unclean spirit in the dry places. Luke XI 24 to 26. Math. XII. 43 to 45

    As to womans benedictions. Luke. XI. 27 to 28.

    Ch. 73

    A sign i.e. a visible proof of his chosen mission called for – instead of a sign he gives reproof and the prophet Jonas. On another occasion according to Mathew the same demand receives the same answers. – dark discourse on the subject of light.

    Luke XI 25 to 36

    Math. XII. 38 to 42 and XI. 22, 23.

    Mark and John silent.

    Ch. 74

    At dinner at a Pharisee’s, Pharisees and lawyers with their ceremony scorned – Scribes and Pharisees endeavour to extract from him a ground of accusation.

    Luke XI. 37 to 54.

    Math. Mark and John silent.

    Ch. 75

    Long discourse to a mixt multitude. Pharisaical Hypocrisy of the Pharisees reprobated. Intrepidity and carelessness of life, coupled with fear of his power, inculcated

    Luke XII 1 to 59 (end)

    Math. VI. 19 to 34 (end)

    Mark and John silent

    Ch. 76

    from the incident of the strengthening of certain Galileans by I I and the lives lost by the fall of a tower at Siloam occasion taken to inculcate repentance, i.e. submission and attachment to him and danger of presuming I I too much in forbearance. The greatest visible sufferers not always the most guilty. If after three years dunging the fig tree is barren it will be cut down.

    Luke XIII 1 to 5.

    Math. silent

    Mark d o. John silent.

    Ch. 77

    At Jerusalem A woman who had been bent double eighteen years – cured by imposition of hands in a synagogue on the sabbath. – The ruler of the synagogue being angry is rebuked. – The adversaries confounded. –

    Luke XIII. 10 to 17

    Math. silent

    Mark silent

    John silent.

    Ch 78.

    Parable of the mustard plant and the leaven – the mustard plant as an example of rapid and extensive growth – the leaven of quickly and extensively spreading influence such will be that of the success of the enterprize when once it commences –

    Luke XIII. 15to 21

    Math. XIII. 31, 32, 33

    Mark IV. 30, 31, 32 –

    John silent.
  • Title: [Jug. True 22 Aug. 1815 Titles]
    Description: Jug. True

    22 Aug. 1815

    Titles of the proposed Chapters with their proposed Contents with reference to the Evangelists from whom they are to be extracted

    II. Principal Period.

    Chapter 1

    The next day after his baptism Jesus receives six disciples: viz. 1. Andrew. 2. Simon. 3. Philip. 4. Nathaniel. 5. James Zebedee’s son. 6. John Zebedee’s Son

    John I 35 to 51.

    Matt. IV. 12 to 22

    Mark I 14 to 20

    (Luke V 1 to 11. Per Luke alone Miraculous draught of fishes.

    Ch. 2

    At Cana in Galilee, Jesus performs his first miracle turning water into wine at the Marriage Feast

    John II. 1 to 11.

    Luke silent.

    Matthew silent

    Mark silent.

    Ch. 3

    At Nazareth, where he had been brought up, intimation of his being the Messiah being for the first time given (by him in a synagogue) Jesus escapes with difficulty from the attempt made by the congregation to cast him down a precipice.

    Luke IV. 14 to 30

    Matt. IV. 12.

    Mark I. 14.

    Ch. 4

    At Jerusalem, Jesus drives the cattle, doves, and money changers out of the Temple: question – on what authority […?]

    John II. 12 to 22

    Luke silent

    Matt. silent

    Mark silent

    Ch. 5

    At Jerusalem, Jesus holds converse with the ruler Nicodemus – regeneration – God’s only begotten son sent to the world.

    John II 23 to (the end) 25. III. 1 to 21.

    Luke silent

    Matthew silent. Mark silent.

    Ch. 6

    Jesus and John baptizing at the same time, John still acknowledges the superiority of Jesus. John III 22 to 36.

    Ch. 7

    Jesus’s converse with the Samaritan woman at the well – Converts procured to him by her in Samaria.

    John IV. 1 to 42

    Luke silent

    Matt. silent

    Mark silent

    Ch. 8

    At Cana in Galilee Jesus’s second Miracle the Nobleman’s son cured at Capernaum.

    John IV. 43 to 54.

    Luke silent.

    Matt. silent.

    Mark silent.

    Ch. 9

    At Jerusalem, at the pool Bethesda Bethesda with five porches near the Sheep-market, a man who for 38 years had had an infirmity which now had rendered him motionless, cured. For this cure, it being the Sabbath day, and for calling God his father, ‘the Jews’ seek to kill Jesus. He denies his being equal to God the father, but declares himself his son and deputy with full powers – announces the general resurrection, and for proof of of his mission appeals to John’s testimony, his own ‘works’ and the ‘Scriptures’ – in particular to ‘Moses’ John V. 1 to 47 (the end) Luke silent, Matt. silent – Mark silent.

    Ch. 10.

    At Capernaum the Devil or unclean spirit made to come out of a man: Luke IV. 31 to 37

    Mark I. 21 to 28.

    Ch. 11.

    Still at Capernaum, Simon Peter’s wife’s mother cured of a fever.

    Luke IV. 38, 39. Math. VIII. 14, 15 Mark I. 29. 30. 31.

    Ch. 12

    At Capernaum immediately after the cure of Simon Peter’s wife’s mother, many sick healed, many devils cast out. Luke IV. 40. 41. Matt. VIII. 16. 17. Mark I. 32 to 34. John silent.

    Ch. 13.

    Preaching in Galilee continued – unspecified diseases healed and devils cast out – followers in multitudes from various places. Luke IV. 42. 43. 44. Math. IV. 23. 24. 25. Mark I. 39.

    Ch. 14

    In a certain city, after the sermon on the mount a leper healed.

    Luke V. 12 to 16. Math VIII. 1 to 4. Mark silent, John silent.

    Ch. 15

    At Capernaum, Pharisees present, a paralytic cured – his sins forgiven.

    Luke V 17 to I I Math. IX. 1 to 8. Mark. II. 1 to 12.

    Ch. 16

    Mathew alias Levi rec d as a disciple. At Mathew’s house Jesus justifies himself to the Pharisees for eating and drinking with publicans. Luke V. 27 to 39. Math. IX. 9 to 17 Mark II 13 to 22.

    Ch. 17.

    Plucking ears of corn on the sabbath – disciples justified to the Pharisees. Luke VI. 1 to 4. Math XII. 1 to 8. Mark II. 23 to 28.

    Ch. 18

    Still At Capernaum in a synagogue on the sabbath a withered hand healed: the healing justified to the pharisees. Luke VI. 6 to 11. Math. XII. 9 to 14. Mark III 1 to 6.

    Ch. 19

    out of his disciples twelve chosen to serve as apostles Luke VI. 12 to 16. Math. X. I I to I I. Mark III. 13 to 19.

    Ch. 20

    Immediately after the selection of the Apostles, and immediately before the preaching on the mount, unspecified cures and dispossessions effected. Luke VI. 17 to 21. Math. XII. 15 to 21. Mark III. 7 to 12. Quere.

    Ch. 21

    Sermon on the mount preached

    Luke VI. 20 to 29 (end)

    Math. V. 1 st to 47 (end)

    Mark silent. John silent.