clxvii. 190]

1820 May 4. See Oct. 30

Part II.

Letter 11. Better Ultramaria rule Spain

"Throw aside your arms". you say to them, and you say well. Throw aside your arms permitt me to say for them to you. No arms have they ever taken /did they ever think of taking/ up against you. It is not in the way of offensive war that they have ever taken up arms against you, or any body: it is only in self-defence: and I grieve to say, if in your state of freedom /the days of your freedom/ you persevere in the conduct you were forced into in the days of servitude in self-defence against you. No attempt have they ever made, to exercise dominion over any part of Spain. No such attempt have they ever made: no such desire have they ever formed.
Similar Items
  • Title: [1820 Oct. 10 Spanish liberticide measures]
    Description: 1820 Oct. 10 Spanish liberticide measures 4 Torreno

    An impartial Spectator may /can/ allow the people of Spain can allow – the

    people of Spain ought to allow for a moment of irritation and alarm – for

    measures that under the influence of those passions present themselves as

    dictated by self-defence. I do not say that merely it is for the interest of the

    Spanish people that for having passed this law the existing rulers should be

    dealt with as they dealt with their predecessors. But I do say that so long as

    this law remains despotism reigns, and that if this law or any thing like it is

    permanent the liberties of Spain are gone: some sort of mixt tyranny nobody can

    foresee what is substituted to the pure Monarchical one. Under the like tyranny

    we in England are groaning. True: but then we have our recollections: we have

    our fixt habits: we have our laws incompatible with all liberty: but then we

    have our habits of acting against law and in spite of law – it is to the

    weakness of our laws that we owe every thing by which we are distinguished to

    our advantage from other nations. We have laws and rules of law in abundance any

    one of which if executed would suffice to divide the whole population into two

    classes – prisoners and jailers.

    Ah! who ever are their rulers, the people of Spain the people of Spain before

    their salvation is accomplished the people of Spain will have much to

    forgive.
  • Title: [1820 June 7 Emancipation Spanish]
    Description: 1820 June 7

    Emancipation Spanish

    '.6. Creoles repugnant

    Spanish America would be for [...?] of [...?] or Ireland was: and with great advantage

    If, on the news of the unexpected change from government despotism to a government in so great /high/ a degree popular, if under the intoxication produced by so felicitous a result, despotism to throw itself /themselves/ into the arms of their liberators, and not only into their arms, but at their feet should [...?] the amount be found very extensively prevalent the wonder would /need/ not be great. But that at the end of a certain interval, when the intoxication had had time to subside, and experience had taken place of hope and confidence, this /a/ disposition /to self-sacrifice/ should continue unchanged, seems far too much to be expected.

    One of two things. Either, to the people of Spain and their rulers, the dominion over Spanish America would manifestly not be of any the smallest use, or in a variety of points and to a great extent, a sacrifice of the interest of the many in America to those of the few in Europe would have to be made. Take a few examples.

    1 In America money would have to be raised by taxes to be sent without equivalent to save taxes to you in Europe

    2. From America, money the proceeds of [...?] would be to be suit for the same purpose.

    3. Under the notion of benefiting the [...?] class among you, restriction would be to be imposed on the production and export of the produce of industry in these distant regions on the productions of the industry of these your American subjects.

    4. To make fortunes for the purpose of their being spent among you and for your benefit. Others in Spanish America, would under the new Constitution, or under the old despotism be to be filled by the choice of your rulers.
  • Title: [1820 Dec r. 27. Rid Yourselves of]
    Description: 1820 Dec r. 27.

    Rid Yourselves of Ultramaria

    '. 1. Creoles Willing

    4. Supposable source the fourth. Emolument

    from Ultramarian offices: Money, which, by Spaniards sent from Spain, might come to

    be received, in the shape of official emolument, attached

    to official situations in Spanish America.

    From this source, no relief in respect of diminution of taxes, would

    be experienced by the subject many in Spain: the benefit, though received by

    Spaniards, would be engrossed by the ruling few, who could not receive it without

    ceasing to be inhabitants of Spain. To p. 9

    5. Supposable source the fifth. Men, for military service: men, sent from Ultramarian Spain

    to serve in a military capacity in Spain. From this source, no relief in respect of

    diminution of taxes, would be experienced by the subject

    many in Peninsula Spain: at a less price than it would cost to import them from

    Ultramaria men might be obtained, for this service, either in Spain, or in some other

    country of Europe: for example in Switerland the hired troops of which country have

    lately with such obvious propriety been dismissed. The foreigners would be well

    affected, or they would not enlist. The Ultramarians, if enlisted by force to be

    banished and thus kept in servitude could not be otherwise than disaffected: and

    voluntarily they could not without premium too enormous to be given be engaged to

    exchange freedom at home to such servitude in a strange and distant region.

    In the above may be seen all the sources, and supposed sources, of supply, at the

    charge of America, /Ultramarian Spain/ that ever have been, or ever (it is believed)

    could be resorted to, under the notion of affording, to the subject many in Spain,

    relief or benefit derived in any [...?] shape from a dominion exercised in that

    country by those by whom the powers of governent are exercised in Peninsula

    Spain.