date

18 May 1808 I. Reasons Ch.V
18 May 1808

I. Reasons

Ch.V. Advantages

§.9./8./ Arbitrary power ousted

In such a state of things, superior reason would go unthanked and unregarded: or if regarded at all, regarded with a degree of jealousy and ill-will proportioned to its superiority: absurdity and nonsense are venerated because self-exempted from all scrutiny: exempted by their very incomprehensibility, a treasure which receives a fresh addition, from every particle of absurdity and nonsense that comes to be added to the heap.

In the indulgences sold at one time by the spiritual Court of Rome, the Protestant beholds a licence for the practice of sin, and because he has been bred a Protestant, disapproves of it. But no vast[?] indulgence was ever more decidedly and incontestably a licence for the practice of spiritual sin, than the principle and practice of nullification is a licence to the Judge for the practice of judicial injustice. Yet by the suitor - and not only in the rank of day-labourer, but in the office of legislator, the possession and exercise of this licence is regarded not merely with indifference, but with admiration and applause with an eye of veneration seconded by a tongue of eulogy. Why? because peer as well as peasant have been bred under a creed, an article of which is that "the law is the perfection of reason", another that "every thing is as it should be."
Similar Items
  • Title: [1817 Nov 25 Not Paul II Doctrine]
    Description: 1817 Nov 25

    Not Paul

    II Doctrine

    Ch In Jesus

    Mary Magdalen

    Error Cause

    But under the religion, as modified by the religion of Paul in proportion as it

    became more and more corrupted by the advantage taken of it to promote worldly

    interests, the power of the spiritual guide came day by day through the course of

    many centuries, to assume a more and more tangible and palpable shape, till at length

    the exercise of it ripened into the shape designated by the name of the sale of

    indulgences. Every sin, and its fine the service rendered by clearing the conscience

    of the apprehension of future punishment of punishment in a future life on the score

    of such /by reason of such/ sin had its fixt price. the more this system of taxation

    approached to its maturity, the more palpable and distinctly liquidated was the

    interest which the spiritual guide thus possessed in the multiplication of the number

    of reputed sins, which each individual who regarded himself as capable of purchasing

    exemption from punishment on the score in question on the terms in question, regarded

    himself as having committed.
  • Title: [19 May 1808 I. Reasons Ch.V]
    Description: 19 May 1808

    I. Reasons

    Ch.V. Advantages

    §.│ │ Jury Trial extended

    11. In these the ordinary Courts Jury trial was employed: in the extraordinary ones it was not employed. But from this difference in actual practice, let it not be supposed that any corresponding difference in point of reason and utility had place, or by the common superordinate of these Judges of all classes had ever been supposed to have place. {Comprehensiveness of design - unity of plan - consistency[?] - every thing of this sort has at all times been unknown to English law.} By Common Law Judges Jury trial was employed, because they had been bred up under it, were accustomed to it, and knew not how to go on without it. By Roman Law, called Civil law Judges of the above three classes Jury trial was not employed because they had not been bred up under it, were not accustomed to it, and did not wish for any such clog[?].

    12. Had it been the fortune of these Civilians, or Civil lawyers as they are called, to have been bred up in the English Common Law Courts, the causes now termed Equity causes, Ecclesiastical causes and Admiralty causes would have been subjected to the cognizance of a Jury (with perhaps an exception to a certain extent in the case of the Admiralty causes).

    Had it been the fortune of the Common Law Judge to have been bred up under judicatories judging Roman Law practice, the sorts of causes now tried by Juries would, in England, have been tried by Judges without Juries, in England as in Scotland, and almost every where else.
  • Title: [19 May 1808 I. Reasons Ch.V]
    Description: 19 May 1808

    I. Reasons

    Ch.V. Advantages

    §.│ │ Jury trial extended

    Questions about the domestic state and condition of the party - married or single - and if married to whom married - another question which under the guidance of chance, presents itself for decision, to either or both of two out of those three Courts - not to say to either or all of all three judicatories.

    So in the case of adultery. In a Spiritual Court the breach of contract thus denominated is a sin, and proved without a Jury, and requires neither the mode of collecting evidence to prove it, nor the admission of unlearned Judges into the judicatory, to pronounce it proved. In a Common Law Court 'it' is a sort of a tort: and now nothing can serve for the proof of it but vivâ voce examination in public with cross-examination, nor for pronouncing whether the proof be sufficient or no, but the lips of one of these unlearned Judges.