JB_092_085.xml

Title: [15 Dec r 1807 Scotch Reform 2]

Description: 15 Dec r 1807

Scotch Reform 2

2

Letter V

Ch.4.

§.5.

Of the genus Stellio[?] in the species hitherto discovered are -

1. Stellio praegravis

(d): Solvent malâ fide Defendant, having possession of the subject matter in dispute, and combating for ultimate success, through indigence and consequent inability on the other side.

2. Stellio tenax

(e): Solvent malâ fide Defendant, combating for intermediate profit, by intermediate use or possession of the matter in dispute.

3. Stellio dissipatorius sivi laceratorius

(f): Insolvent malâ fide Defendant, combating for the intermediate faculty of embezzlement or dissipation.

4. Stellio fortinicola[?] (g): Solvent or Insolvent malâ fide Defendant, combating for ultimate success and intermediate profit, through intervening casualties; such as deposition of evidence, death of one or other party &c. +See Table. Mischiefs of Delay:

5. Stellio iratus

(h): Solvent or Insolvent malâ fide Defendant, combating for the gratification of the irascible appetite, by the intermediate destruction or deterioration of the matter in his possession or power, to the prejudice of the right owner.

6. Stellio cuniculus / vulpes sive (i): Solvent malâ fide Defendant, taking the benefit of the Insolvency-licence, granted to him who, from a shape in which the Judge does not refuse, chooses to convert the matter in dispute the shape of landed or other property, in which the Judge does refuse to lay hands on it, for the purposes of justice.

091-212.xml

Title: [17 Feb y 1808 on L d Eldon's Bill]

Description: 17 Feb y 1808

on L d Eldon's Bill

Letter VI

Omissa & Facienda

1. No reporting

I. Directions for the encouragement of malâ fide wrongdoers against (good out-door parlance[?] and agents) in the character of malâ fide defendants of all six sorts.

II. Directions for the more effectual encouragement of malâ fide wrongdoers in the character of solvent defendants combating for ultimate success through indigence on the other side - See below directions concerning malâ fide Plaintiffs.

III. Directions for the encouragement of malâ fide wrongdoers in the character of solvent defendants combating for intermediate profit, arising out of delay, and proportioned to the length of it. or Particular directions concerning defendants combating for intermediate profit.

IV. Directions for /Particular directions concerning/ the more special[?] encouragement of malâ fide wrongdoers in the character of insolvent defendants combating for the intermediate faculty of embezzlement or destitution or wilful damage in gratification of enmity.

V. Directions for /Particular Directions concerning/ the more efficient encouragement of defendants solvent or insolvent combatting for ultimate success through casualties /delays by means of [...?] destructive[?]/.

VI. Particular Directions concerning defendants combating for gratification of enmity - See below Directions concerning malâ fide Plaintiffs.

VII. Particular Directions concerning solvent Defendants taking the benefit of an insolvency licence.

In one instance /case/, and that a very exclusive one, composing the whole business of the Bill Chamber, extraordinary difficulty /difficulty/ is in a book of practice+ stated as the signal looked to by the Lord Ordinary for [...?] a cause out of his hands without decision instead of deciding in it, [...?] for reporting instead of advising. "All Bills are advised by the Lord Ordinary in the first instance, unless his Lordship thinks there is difficulty in which case he reports the same to the Court, verbally at the foot of the Table, and pronounces such interlocution[?] [...?], as is warranted by the opinions [...?] delivered[?]."

The course they take for getting the better of /mastering/ extraordinary difficulties is truly curious. Where there is no difficulty, the case receives it decision from a single Judge, who has been keeping all the documents in his hands any number of months at pleasure, with the faculty of recurring to them any number of times and for any length of time at his leisure. When difficulty calls for proportionable examination and meditation[?], it is to be got rid of by a crowd of Judges huddled together each of them taking his conception of the case from what he can pack up from vivâ voce statement of the learned Reporter who stares[?] [...?] in [...?] in the station of a secture[?] rather than a Judge, expects in /looks[?] to/ the termination of the conference for the faculty of extracting himself from a situation thus irksome and incongruous.

/To cover incapacity, and escaper from responsibility - yes: but is this the way to conquer difficulty, and do justice to the cause?/

+Board 265, 279.

JB_092_090.xml

Title: [9 July 1807 + D Scotch Reform]

Description: 9 July 1807

+ D

Scotch Reform

18

2 o

Letter V

II. Litig. promot

v. Particular Directions concerning the species of Stellio stiled fortunicola: composed of malâ fide defendants, solvent or insolvent, combating for ultimate success through delay, by means of title-destruction casualties.

1. In regard to such casualties as naturally and of themselves possess this property, such as deposition of evidence, do what you can to favour their taking effect: concerning which see above, p. │ │.

2. These not being of themselves sufficient, take any casualties whatever, the more numerous and diversified the better, and bestow upon them this force and virtue - for examples, see above p. │ │.

3. To make room for casualties of both sorts to take place, as well as for so many other good purposes, remember to have ready for the market, in addition to the minimum which you provide and establish gratis, as large an assortment of delays, and in pieces of the greatest length, as possible: besides those which the customers on both sides are forced to buy, whether they will or no.

VI. Particular Directions concerning solvent Defendants combating for gratification of enmity:

Whether in the Station of defendant or plaintiff, wrongdoer before or without litigation, defendant upon and in consequence of litigation, i.e. of a demand made in the quality of plaintiff claiming satisfaction for the wrong, plaintiff not having sustained any wrong, but claiming satisfaction on that pretence, on the pretence of having ascertained it, the more mischief you put it in the power of a man to do to another, the more extensive and prosperous this branch of your trade. This faculty, the jus urandi[?], you will take care to put in every man's power to purchase, and to the largest amount possible, in either capacity, and so leave it to his choice. The best choice he can take is certainly to become suited, viz. Plaintiff in the first instance, because in this case your profit is if any thing more certain than his, though both go hand in hand: whereas in the other case viz. when he committs the wrong in the first instance, and without coming to your shop for tools, if the party wronged is to such a degree helpless or timorous or well informed and prudent as not to take any legal steps to right himself the wrongdoer gains his ends without you and robs you of your due: but as to this you must take your chances.