date

3 March 1808 36 Letter V
3 March 1808

36

Letter V

§.4. Reasons

Thus, let us come at once to the most determinate and highly authoritative example: {and to render it the more determinate, let us take not merely a sort of case but an individual case.}

In the House of Lords, when, on the occasion of any individual cause, calling for the decision of that branch of the legislature, in its capacity of a judicatory, immediate or appellate, it is deemed necessary or convenient that a parcel of law should be made, that branch of the legislature not being recognized as competent to make laws of its sole authority, the custom is to call in the 12 Judges, and to give over to them the commission of supplying the demand. That which on these solemn and sublime occasions is never made but always declared is the law; that which on these same occasions is always made - always made whether declared or not declared - is the reasons.

Where a portion though an undivided one of the deity is the subject, theologians, to whom this branch of natural history presents no difficulty, have a distinction between making and begetting: where a portion of human law is the subject, lawyers have a corresponding distinction between making and declaring. Where reasons those of which the 12 Judges are the makers are the subject, ask for the makers, there they are: ask for the declarers whether the reasons are ever declared or no, there again they are. Where the law to which those reasons are spoken of or attached is the subject, ask for the declarers, there again they are: ask for the makers, you might as well ask the Sheriff for John Doe, they are never to be found.
Similar Items
  • Title: [4 Feb y 1807 Omitt or Postpone 11]
    Description: 4 Feb y 1807

    Omitt or Postpone 11

    Letter IV

    Resolut 6.7.8.9.

    Juries

    Lawyers the fondness

    4. Class the 4 th. Causes which by reason of their complexity and although the whole mass of evidence which the case furnished be fothcoming, are by reason of their complexity incapable of being gone through in the compass of a single sitting.

    In regard to causes of this description nature has rendered it strictly speaking impossible that they should be heard[?] throughout by a Jury, tried with the benefit of all the wisdom, and all the observations required by that evidence is matter of physical impossibility.

    In English proactive causes of this description, are in great numbers submitted in show and pretence to the cognizance of a Jury. What is impossible is to try the cause /do the business/. What is not possible, is - to receive the fees in pretence of trying it /received for doing it/.

    Receiving money of false pretences is in some cases felony: but these are where the receivers are weak and helpless: subject to the laws, not makers[?] of laws in pretence of being declarers.
  • Title: [3 March 1808 39 Letter V]
    Description: 3 March 1808

    39

    Letter V

    §. Reasons

    In bringing to view the above cases in the character of precedents in recommendation of the practice of giving reasons for accompaniments to law, I did not mean it was no part of my intention to give the practice of the reasons themselves as a sample, in respect of quality, of the sort of reason which I would wish to see furnished by our proposed sub-legislators, nor of the course pursued in the preparation of those such reasons.

    1. Not of the quality - for of about twenty sorts of reasons which under the name of reasons or some term meant to be synonymous Lord Coke speaks of as the sources from whence that only estimable part of the law which is in the form of jurisprudential law is deduced, two only or at most three make any the most distant reference to the welfare of those, to whose welfare statute law always professes, and with here and there an exception, is to be directed: and such is the nature of this species of law, that after the prodigious quantity of it that has been thus made declared I should have said with views opposite to those of public utility - with intentions directed to the sanction of the interest if the rest of the community to the interest of the declarers, the grounding it on reasons drawn from the consideration of what otherwise would have been the interest of the community would by the shock given to certainty enhance the mischief instead of remove it.
  • Title: [Feb y 1807 + +[?] A From Letter]
    Description: Feb y 1807

    + +[?] A

    From Letter IV

    Resolut. 6.7.8.9

    Juries

    Lawyers or people?

    In Geneva advocates paid by honour[?], as Justices of Peace in England

    My Lord the wonders could not be comparatively great - far greater wonders have been seen - if some grave and deeply learned, or even without being law-learned, deeply politicated[?] and Machiavellically-instructed person, should accost your Lordship in a whisper, and by profound, or rather by sublime argument (sublime it must be the air being the region which it must never quit) - should insist that some of this sort, to a certain degree of extent and accuracy[?], are absolutely necessary to be running on the body politic, less professional learning should want food to feed upon. Changing the figure for that figure is too near the truth to be [...?]. The Constitution (it will be said) rests upon the law, and law upon the shoulders of the men of law. If Atlas were laid low, where would be that world to which he is now so generous as to lend his learned shoulders?

    Taking up then the Atlas argument - and admitting the irrefragability of it,- for, as substance is wanting, to it, frangibility is so too - admitting that in the shape of injustice and misery, there is a price, the payment of which in return for such sublime security would be good economy, still would come the question, what price, and thence of the price at present paid for it, whether some thing might be spared?

    All these questions /considerations/ your Lordship will understand, though travelling over English ground, travel there in theory - and in search of illustration merely[?], Scotland brings the goal on which they terminate. Many running over England, all looking to Scotland, and Scotland merely with any view to practise. For in Scotland, it is admitted in all hands[?] that there are some things as they should not be, though in England as Blackstone certifieth /as we learn over and over again from Blackstone, every thing is and always /ever/ has been, and ever will be as it should be.

    When a Bill for the drawing of a fee has been lying on the table, whatever petitions it may have had to encounter, I do not remember to have met with any from an association of apothecaries or urging on a ground of for the rejection of the measure the decrease threatened to be made by it in the number of [...?] and thence in the prosperity of the profession and art of healing. But then some in which that really useful and really learned branch of labour is displayed is confined to the sick-room: it ascends not to the Cabinet, or to either House.