1822 Aug. 12.

or 1.

Power is mischievous

in so far as needless.

Of factitious dignity, the

whole.

or 2.

1. At the expence of all

it is conferred.

or 3.

Its produce is - not obedience

indeed but obsequiousness;

i.e conformaty

to another's will.

or 4.

Persons to whom it

produces obsequiousness

are

1. The patron.

2. The dignitary

Towards the patron

most.

or 5.

Opinions it produces

1. That to the dignitary

belong power, opulence

and the good will of

the patron. This is commonly

more or less

true.

2 them, endowments

tending to render him

contributory to greatest

happiness, this is

always false.

or 6.

Factitious dignity is

the factitious cause

of factitious respect.

or 7.

Its product a confused

and indeterminate

mass of opinions

and conceptions

Principal ingredients

are —

1. In the dignitary, power

preeminent.

2. In d. o opulence d. o

3. D. o in habits with

men equal and even

superior in dignity,

and thence, or otherwise,

in power and

opulence.

or 7 contin. d

4. In d. o place in the

patron's esteem or affection

or both: thence

chance of obtaining

for others benefits such

as the patron can bestow.

5. In d. o qualities giving

him means and will

to contribute to greatest

happiness. True,

the first four false,

the 5th true, the reverse.

or 8.

curious and lamentable

its efficiency in the

production of the false

opinion, mischievous as

it is.

or 9.

In every case, the dignity

has for evidence of

its existence the instrument

or act by which

it is conferred: accompanied

commonly with

some symbol visible

and conspicuous, ex.

, ribbon, star, medal,

etc.

or 10.

Efficient cause of this

power in symbols or

signs, the associations

of ideas.

or 11.

Curious the irresistible

force with which they

operate in the production

of this effect.

Behold a set of men

whom taken in the aggregate

my judgment

pronounces below the

average in the scale of

worth, moral and intellectual.

yet by the sight of

any one is produced

the conception of the opposite

superiority.

or 12.

Cause of the inconsistency

train of associations

produced by authority in

all shapes and from all

sources from the earliest

dawn of reason. For

the introduction of the

false conception a amount the

of turn of a moment suffices: for

the expulsion, if at all nothing

less than a train of reflections.

can suffice

or 13.

So in case of Ghosts &

At the first moment of

Darkness opens the door

Imagination renders them present.

To bunch their

with the of judgment

judgment can it

great can through

during long life

existence in Ghosts is the

not more fabulous

than worth, moral or intellectual,

in those creatures

of Monarchy, State

Dignitaries.

or 14.

Source or corroboration

of the error, adulation adulation,

chief instrument of dissemination,

books; first

the pen, now the press.

In dignitaries, writers have

beholden possessors of power

and opulence to which,

in return for eulogy, they

have looked for benefit

to themselves.

Of the receipt of those benefits

the probability (they

say) would be not as the

moral or intellectual

worth of the dignitary:

such as his kindness towards

them, which again

would be as the intensity

of their eulogy on him.

or 15.

Factitious dignity, has it

in any stage of society

been contributory to greatest

happiness?

or 16.

Evil this institution has

been proved above. Needless,

by experience: viz of

: original number 13.

Ch. Factitious Dignity

G.

§. I. Factitious Dignity what

§ Cause of the

upon it. G

§ by it

, 4. 5

Magnitude of and

and un

conquerable of

. 11. 12. 13

cause of the

influence associate

. 8. 9. 10. 11.

Its effect in the conduct

and mind of parties interested.

3. 4. 5

Its mischievousness

1. 2. 19. 1 8

present & 24.

of the elements of effective

power this one

excluded; the

government not impaired,

but improved:

all benefits greater

without than with

it.
Similar Items
  • Title: [1821 July 10 1822 Aug. 11. Codification]
    Description: 1821 July 10 1822 Aug. 11.

    Codification Offer? or First Lines Constitutional?

    Factitious Dignity excluded

    2. Factitious mischievous

    III Factitious Dignity

    III Factitious Dignity. Power is purely mischievous as to all that is not needless /whatsoever of it is not needful/. Factitious Dignity is in the whole of it purely mischievous. At the expence of the whole - not only of the greatest number but of the whole, is all power created and conferred. At the expence of the whole, is all factitious dignity created and conferred Of operative power the constitutive cause and at the same time the immediate effect is not only obsequiousness but obedience on the part of him over /on/ whom it is exercised. Of factitious dignity the /an/ effect is not obedience indeed but obsequiousness on the part of those at whose expence it is created and conferred. In so far as it is productive of this effect, it is by producing in the minds of those at whose expence it is created the opinion of the existence of superiority either in respect of useful moral and intellectual endowments, or in respect of power, opulence, separately or collectively on the part of him on whom it is conferred, and by whom it is accordingly possessed.

    In so far as it is productive of obsequiousness though without actual obedience, it does not indeed confer power on the individual on whom it is conferred, but in his favour it produces the effect of power - conformity to /as towards/ his will. At the same time it creates and conferrs power and in much greater amplitude /quantity/ in favour of him by whom it is itself created and conferred, in favour of the patron of the dignity. For the patron of the dignity is himself the most dignified of all the dignitaries - possessors of the dignity of which be is patron.

    On the part /In the case/ of him on whom it is conferred - of him by whom it is possessed - in a word the Dignitary - so far as regards the possession of power and opulence this opinion is commonly well-grounded and just /true/. But in so far as regards the possession of /useful/ endowments moral and intellectual useful, namely to the greatest number and by means of a tendency to the augmentation of their happiness, it is not to this opinion but the reverse of it, that is well grounded and true. The cause of its being so is in this case the same as in the case of excessive opulence and superfluous power, as above.
  • Title: [1821 July 10 Codification Offer]
    Description: 1821 July 10

    Codification Offer

    '.9 /Factitious Dignity [...?]/

    2. Factitious mischievous

    III. Factitious dignity

    Factitious dignity is the factitious cause of factitious respect.

    The respect of which it is productive has for its more remote cause a confused and indeterminate mass of opinions or conceptions - a mass of which, severally or in a greater or less number collectively, the following seem to be the ingredients.

    1. Opinion of the existence of preeminent power on the part of the dignitary.

    2. Opinion of the existence of preeminent opulence on the part of the dignitary.

    3. Opinion of the dignitary's being in the habits of personal converse with other persons possessed of the same of equal and even inferior /superior/ dignities and thence or otherwise of equal end even superior masses of power and opulence.

    4. Opinion of the dignitary's having a place in the esteem or affection or both, of the patron of the dignity - thence of his having a chance more or less considerable of obtaining for other persons those /such/ benefits as it is in the power of such patron to bestow.

    5. Opinion of his being in a preeminent degree in possession of qualities extremely useful - of qualities such as while they afford him the power or means conferr on him the disposition to render his exertions /endeavour/faculties/ conducive to the greatest happiness of the greatest number. All but the last three opinions are in a degree more or less considerable sure to be well-founded. Only in the instance of the last is it ill founded, the opposite being the opinion that, as above, has truth on its side.
  • Title: [1821 July 10 Codification Offer]
    Description: 1821 July 10

    Codification Offer

    '.9

    2 Factitious mischievous

    III. Factitious Dignity

    In the case /situation/ of him by whom the dignity is conferred - in a word in the case of the Patron of the Dignity - it is in this case that its mischievousness is at the highest pitch. On the dignitary himself it conferrs, if not strictly speaking power at any rate the equivalent of power - a means of influencing will, the good enjoyment of which is independent on good behaviour, and which as shewn in the case of power and opulence in excess is thereby /as such/ affords encouragement and incitement to ill-behaviour exempting a man from the restraint and consequently the suffering attached in a greater or less degree to the exercise of official benevolence in its two opposite aspects positive and negative. On the Patron of the Dignity it conferrs in like manner actual power in possession the enjoyment of which is as above an encouragement to ill behaviour and thence not only as in the other case mischievous, but in a prodigiously higher degree: for in his power is included the sum of all the portions of power possessed by all the several dignitaries possessors of the dignity of which he is patron: and in that same proportion does it give encrease to /magnify/ the power and thence the inclination to pursue personal happiness at the expence of the greatest happiness of the greatest number.

    Factitious Dignity is the factitious cause or productive instrument of factious respect.