date

1818 Aug. 25 Government Things
1818 Aug. 25

Government

Things as they are: or First lines &c.

§.1. Misrule Necessity

6

6

9. In /Under/ a democracy whether self ruling or representative, self-regarding interest will in like manner be in every breast predominant. It will therefore be so in the breast of every member of the representative body. On such occasions Every such member would if he could sacrifice to his own personal interest the interest of the whole people. Without the concurrence of a majority of that whole body no such member can make any such sacrifice /as such can do that or any thing else/. If a majority could agree and continue long enough in such their trust they would act as an aristocracy, they would sacrifice the interest of the rest of the people to that interest which they have in common. But, by the supposition, acting on this ocasion they can not continue long enough in such their trust /situation/. For power on one part exerts not but in proportion to obedience /obsequiousness/ on the other. What the people are disposed to is to pay obedience /shew obsequiousness/ to the objects of their confidence, so long as but no longer than, they are regarded by them as abstaining from those acts by which the interest of the people is /would be/ sacrificed to the interests of all or any of these their delegates and so long as they continue so, their rulers. In the event of his concurring in the endeavour to make any such sacrifice, that which no such representative sees before him is any tolerable /considerable/ chance of success: that which every one sees before him is a certainty of dismission which is itself a punishment, coupled with a chance more or less considerable of ulterior punishment.

Under a Monarchy no such unpleasant chance does the Monarch see: under an Aristocracy no such unpleasnt chance does any member of the Aristocracy see.

A representative democracy is therefore not a government of misrule: and it is the only one that is not so. it is in its essence a good government; and the only one that is so.
Similar Items
  • Title: [1820 July 25 Emancipation Spanish]
    Description: 1820 July 25

    Emancipation Spanish

    Summary

    Corruptive influence

    The torrent of rapacity and corruption being thus continually rolling

    on and like an avalanche ever encreasing as it rolls, every form of government but

    one is doomed sooner or later to destruction /self-destruction/: that form of

    government is a representative democracy: formed on the combined principles of

    secrecy (whence alone genuineness) virtual universality, virtual /practical/ equality

    and virtual annuality of suffrage.

    True it is - that In /Under/ a representative Democracy, as under

    every other human government the same predominance of self-regarding over social

    interest has place. In the breast of every public functionary the same endeavour has

    accordingly /has/ place or rather if it saw any prospect of success would have place

    - the same endeavour to make sacrifice of the universal interest, to any extent, to

    personal interest in every imaginable shape. But under a representative democracy

    constituted as above no such prospect of success ever does present itself to any eye

    or eyes capable of taking any chance for realizing it. For, whereas, under every

    other government, there are situations in which one and the same man or set of men

    can by his own hands or those of others conbining plundering, oppressing and

    corrupting as occasion calls without end, under a representative government as above,

    there never is any such person: every member of the corporation of the ruling few

    being not only removable but appointed, immediately or intermediately, by the subject

    many
  • Title: [1818 Aug. 25 Things as they are or]
    Description: 1818 Aug. 25

    Things as they are or First lines &c.

    §.4. Instruments in Mixt Monarchy - Corruption

    {4}

    {11}

    {4}

    The English government /Monarchy/ is not a pure Monarchy. It is a mixt Monarchy. In it the Monarch has for his incumbrances not only an under-aristocracy called the House of Lords, but a sort of democratical representative body or at least the shadow of it called the House of Commons. Neither purchasable pleasure nor court service, nor standing army, nor so much as instruments for the carrying on the civil branch /business/ of government can he get so long as the forces of the Constitution remain unchanged without the consent of the sub[?] Aristocracy in an Assembly, and that of the sort of partially representative body in which what small portion of democracy /democratical government/ is to be found any where is to be found. The Members of the House of Lords are the declared and professed guardians of one anothers’ rights of the /that/ share of power of which they are respectively partakers. They exist not scarcely do they pretend /profess/ to exist for the use of the whole people, or for any use but that of the Monarch and that of one another: if any assignable service rendered by them or any of them as such to the people at large scarcely would any one real example be to be found. In their past and present existence consists, in the ground of public utility their sole title to future existence.

    The Members of the House of Commons are in profession and outward shew Guardians of the people’s rights such they accordingly profess /stile/ to be as often as in the formal language they have occasion to address themselves to the King /Monarch/, to the House of Lords, and to the people whose representatives they profess to be is - so many delegates, chosen by the people, and having in all parts the same interest with the people: chosen each of them by an adequate part of the people, chosen freely by that part, and not either in return for a bribe, or for fear of unjust suffering: chosen by the people by so many portions of the people /constituents/, in full persuasion of their pursuing each of them the interest of that the portion and thence all of them of the whole: chosen in that expectation, and thence liable each of them at any time to be removed from the trust /delegated power/ in the event of his being regarded by his constituents as having made a bad or even an insufficient use of it.
  • Title: [[lxxxiv. 130] 1822 Jany 30 B ulto]
    Description: [lxxxiv. 130]

    1822 Jany 30 B ulto

    Codification Offer

    ulto

    ?.5. Admission Universal

    ?.5. Members unapt

    After inserting the Explanation as above go on there.

    In every government, with only the above mentioned exeption the ruling few with the assistance of portion more or less considerable of such of the influential few as are not of the number of the ruling few, are, ever have been, and ever will be continually occupied in the making of the sinister sacrifice.

    With the exception of a headless Aristocracy, the examples of which past and present are too few in number and extent, and at the same time too incapable of encrease to present on the present occasion a demand for any further notice, all /every/ governments that is, has been, or ever will be are either pure Monarchy, a mixt Monarchy or pure Representative Democracy.

    1. In a pure Represenatative Democracy the sinister sacrifice is to any considerable extent, manifestly impracticable: it is therefore never endeavoured to be made

    In a pure Monarchy the sinister sacrifice is already consummated.

    In a Mixt Monarchy, it is made by degrees by a junction /the joint [...?]/ between the Monarch and the Representatives of the people. Like the human body It contains in it the seeds of its own [...?], and sooner or later that [...?] is virtue and [...?] According to the mutual disposition of these two antagonizing powers /forces/ with relation to one another. As these two powers have a conjunct sinister interest, so has each of them a separate sinister interest. According as the one or the other prevails, they will at each moment of time be in a state of conflict or of amity. At a time of /In case of/ continued conflict the representati of the people, if they have the people on their side will rid themselves of the Monarch. If they continue in a state of [...?] they will go, making [?] on each occasion the sinister sacrifice, till at length the system of oppression and depredation being given institution, the people will rid themselves of both together and on the ruin of the Monarchic Aristocratical tyranny set up a pure democracy