date

1819 Dec. 5 Bentham’s Radical
1819 Dec. 5

Bentham’s Radical

Prelim

II. Necessity

6

1

If the exclusion thus put upon discourse where[?] confined to spoken language /speech/, there would in some cases be not only /merely/ plausible pretence but sound reason. Why? Because by speech a man might be forced to receive into his mind that which would hurt his feelings subject him to a pain which there would be no use[?] as his being subjected to, at the pleasure of a wrongdoer /an offender[?]/ an unfailing person might be thus injured /afflicted/ /subjected to this affliction/ and he would have no means of saving himself from it. A man’s piety might thus be wounded by that which in his case is blasphemy: a woman’s modesty by that which in her case is indecent language.

But by written discourse how are any man’s feelings to be wounded unless he chooses they should be so. The book is in his hands: so long as he likes it, he reads it: the instant he comes to any thing which he does not like he lays it down what could any reasonable man wish /have/ for more.

Oh but the rising generation be[?] but children of blasphemy is[?] sedition be sufficed to circulate, their minds their tender minds may /will/ be pierced[?] by it. Their tender minds pierced[?] by it! Oh […?]! these children have they not Parents or other Guardians? Is it that their Guardians who knew them care nothing for them, and the only persons who care any thing for them, are gone[?] to where they are unknown[?] and have not any inducements[?] for caring for them comparable to that which you have for caring for your own dogs and horses.
Similar Items
  • Title: [1819 Dec r. 5 Bentham’s Radical]
    Description: 1819 Dec r. 5

    Bentham’s Radical

    Prelim

    II. Necessity

    Utopian &c

    4

    What simpleton has there ever been more silly, than the men who not only are in the constant […?] indulge themselves in this sort of lines sort of language but ground all their measure upon the assumption of the truth of it, would be were there a grain[?] of […?] among them, be all be. But among them there is no such silliness: to assert it of them would be calumny Not one of them so ignorant as not to know himself, and that fully for which he is not to know not only what he himself is but to what the idol is, upon that he himself may […?] in for his share of the worship to worship. (a)

    Note (a)

    (a) If among the vendors of blasphemy some of the most mischievous was to be punished, the vendors of Blackstone’s Commentaries[?] would be thus punished. plus[?] If to ascribe to man the attributes of Almighty God to blasphemy, the Power of blasphemy was that Blackstone for to the King of England to every King of England he ascribes in so many words the attributes of Almighty God, and page after page, calls upon subjects to worship him as such.
  • Title: [1831 July 15 Parliamentary Candidates]
    Description: 1831 July 15

    Parliamentary Candidates Declaration

    V. Education for All.

    4

    Oh[?] ye[?] But I would not see tyranny[?] cloven-foot govern under

    the mask of piety

    Suppose a School set on foot /A School suppose is opened/ but not

    only useful knowledge in other shapes /at large/ is taught, but instruction in the

    subject of religion in the form in which it is imparted by the teachers of one alone

    of the [...?] number of the seats, and that one the teachers of which are in the pay

    of government. What is the consequence? Denied of useful knowledge to one part of the

    people: a pretence given for insincerity and insincerity thereby produced in the

    minds of no one knows how large a part of those to whom it is not desired. Of those

    Parents and Guardians who do not choose that on this all important subject opinions

    different from their own should be entertained by their children none will send their

    children to the School: and how small is the number of those Parents and Guardians

    who /whom/ on this all-important subject opinions different from their own should be

    entertained by their children! to all those children the useful knowledge imparted at

    that school is denied: and the children to whom it is thus important are those not

    those only who if the seat they belong be no different from that the constituted

    authorities profess to belong to are content[?] /consent/ in the view of it the

    Members of the seat that on this all important subject their children shall receive

    [...?] instruction, and at that price to purchase for their children /at that price/

    whatsoever useful instruction they receive
  • Title: [1819 Decr 3 §.6 Bentham’s Radical]
    Description: 1819 Decr 3 §.6

    Bentham’s Radical §.6

    Reform Necessary

    §.6 Means employed for supporting the delusion

    5

    He who manifests respect to factitious dignity is necessary to all the mischief done by means of it.

    Factitious Dignity - Of all the instruments of misrule one of the most mischievous is that by which the opinion[?] of most[?] is attached to factitious dignity is the most degrading to the minds on which by many of these instruments the delusion on which that action depends have been propagated with success.

    Suppose no such instruments no such deceptious evidence[?] to have place, opinion causing most and machines[?] serves will have nothing to direct and form it but reality of such reason[?]. Every man would be judged according[?] to his works.

    When on[?] a man has no chance for obtaining respect for other cause than that of his good behaviour it is his interest to behave well: the quantity of respect he receives will be greater and greater the greater the degree to which he has behaved well: in case of extra service rendered to the public at large, the greater the value of that service.

    When tokens of respect is received by a man for other cause than that of good behaviour, the greater the quantity of respect due to the receiver, the greater the interest he has in not behaving well. Be his situation in life what it may, good behaviour can not be maintained without the making of some sacrifices: of sacrifices of personal interest in other shapes to a man’s interest in respect /on the score/ of reputation. But if good be it in what shape it may, without the sacrifice which a man can obtain good in any other shape, he will not make sacrifice.