1822 May 17

Economy etc

These things considered, to propose any such thing as a law prohibiting

/inhibiting/ a member of the legislative body from accepting /the acceptance of/

any such endowed office, and this too under any such notion as that of its

preventing him from doing the will of the Chief functionary /giver of these good

gifts/ to the detriment of the whole community is either imbecillity or

hypocrisy and imposture. It is imbecillity if by the proposer of the law in

question the utter inefficiency of it to its professed end is not observed:

imposture and hypocrisy if it is observed: imposture because a design /desire/

is expressed which in fact is not entertained: hypocrisy because the design

/desire/ if really entertained and pursued and the gratification of it

endeavoured at would be a publickly beneficial and laudable one. So far from

contributing to prevent the supreme legislative functionaries from sacrificing

the universal interest to their own personal and sinister interests in

partnership with that of the Chief Executive functionary so far from preventing

or contributing to prevent the sinister sacrifice, the tendency of any such law

would be to give facility and encrease to it. How? even by producing on the part

of the community at large a /the/ persuasion that by this means the formation

and carrying on of the sinister partnership was /stands/ prevented, and thereby

preventing men from looking out for any arrangements which should in any degree

/reality as well as profession/ be preventive of it.

Qui facit per alium facit per se. Qui recipit per alium recipit per se. Qui

recipit patitur. Qui recipit bonum, bene patitur.
Similar Items
  • Title: [1822 May 17 Economy Ch. 5 Search]
    Description: 1822 May 17

    Economy

    Ch. 5 Search for Money Maximized

    1.

    III. Security 3. Minimizing money at disposal of highest functionaries.

    1. Necessary the office of Chief Executive functionary 2. Desirable its being in a single hand. 3. Necessary in his hands to a great extent power of locating subordinates. 4. And of dislocating them.

    2.

    Necessary to an indeterminate extent power of remuneration for engaging their acceptance.

    3.

    For aptly executing functions to which no power is attached, men may be engaged by compulsion, witness privates in military service by land and sea. Not for executing functions to which power is attached: evil consequence would be desertion and negligence: things of persons subject to their power would remain unemployed or ill—employed. For not doing that which it is not known he can do man can not be punished.

    4.

    Pay therefore can not be altogether withdrawn from office — of offices to a large extent the location can not be in any other hand than that of a chief executive functionary who himself is in a state of subordination to the situation of the body in which as above the greatest happiness of the greatest number requires that the suppressed operative power be lodged.

    5.

    Preventing chief—functionary from producing in the minds of the legislative functionaries by giving endowed offices to others, the same effect as if those offices were given to themselves is not possible: for I. Of the communication of benefit from the endowed functionary to the legislative functionary, no adequate evidence can the nature of the case afford. II. Laws not enactible. 1. Law punishing A the legislative functionary for B's acceptance of an office. 2. Law invalidating the the location of every man having any connection of

    5 contin d.

    of interest or sympathy with any legislative functionary. 3. Law, by punishment or invalidation, inhibiting A from being motivated by a kindness done to B. 4. Law, inhibiting A from doing the will of C on account of his having done, or being expected to do a kindness to B.

    6.

    As a means of preventing a legislative functionary from doing the sinister will of the Chief Executive (giver of good gifts) to propose a law inhibiting d o functionary from receiving such gifts himself is imbecility or hypocrisy & treachery: imbecility if he sees not the inexpediency; treachery if he does — the tendency of such false being to avert the public mind from efficient d o.: to cause men to think the sinister sacrifice is already prevented, as well as intended to be prevented: whereas it is intended to be promoted. Axiom of psychological pathology — Qui facit per alium, facit per se.

    7.

    Placing this within reach of legislative per se functionary good gifts at the disposal of the Chief Executive, is sowing in the Constitution seeds of corruptive influence: enabling and exciting Executive and Executive to become accomplices in trust—breaking (like placing flesh in ) circumstances, yet this is the work of necessity & unavoidable.

    8.

    For preventing effective corruption, i.e. joint performance of the sinister sacrifice, sole means minimizing the quantity & value of the matter of corruption in Chief functionaries, with the application of counterforces as below. This the Interest of both that the quantity and value if it be maximized.
  • Title: [26 May 1804 I 411 Slavery repugnant]
    Description: 26 May 1804

    I 411

    Slavery repugnant to natural law

    I 412

    English law abhors slavery

    I 413

    Natural equity that hiring for an unspecified time should be for a year

    I 417

    Master bringing an action for damage done to his serv t must be assign his own loss

    I 417

    Qui facit per alium, facit per se

    I 421

    Spiritual Courts act pro salute animae

    I 423

    Marriage prohibited between certain persons by God's law

    I 423

    Disabilities to marriage grounded on natural law

    I 428

    Indissolubility of marriages built on divine revealed law

    I 430

    Husband and wife one person

    I 431

    Abjuration of realm = death

    I 431

    Husband & wife not to give evidence ag t each other because they are one person

    I 435

    Natural law for parents to provide for their children

    I 436

    Children disinherited without a sufficient ground assigned may move to have the will set aside on the ground of their parent's loss of reason.

    I 438

    Parents protect their children from a natural duty

    I 441

    Children owe duty to their parent from a principle of natural justice

    I 451

    All persons infants till 21

    I 455

    Corporations immortal

    I 456

    A corporation one person

    I 457

    King, bishops &c, a sole corporation

    I 458

    Parsons never die — every parson being the self same individual as his most remote predecessors

    I 460

    Common law a custom, arising from the agreem t of the whole community

    I 462

    Que facit per alium, facit per se

    I 463

    Corporation an invisible body

    I 463

    — its existence ideal — has no soul

    I 469

    King inspects all corporations in the Kings Bench

    I 472

    Dissolution of a corporation its civil death

    II 3

    Right to property founded on the reveal'd will

    II 3

    Law of nature confers property in first possessor

    II 7

    Originally men had a natural right to occupy any lands

    II 7

    Law of nature allows migration to deserts

    II 8

    By natural law & natural justice occupancy conveys right to possession

    II 9

    By universal law property remains in the taker

    II 10

    Universal law a secondary law of nature

    II 13

    By law of nature upon death of possessor his property should become common

    II 16

    Division of property into personal and real

    II 18

    Land = estates

    II 18

    By law of nature water common

    II 20

    Incorporeal hereditaments

    II 22

    Conveyance of patronage invisible and mental

    II 31

    A rank modus is felo de se

    II 33

    Distinction between common appendant & d o appartenant — a right to put animals that do & do not the ground

    II 37

    Public offices not to be sold the certain consequence being extortion on the purchaser

    II 72

    Corruption of blood

    II 76

    Functions dyslogistically epithetized

    I 105

    All... lands... are... holden... of the King

    I 109

    Corporation never dies

    I 109 The King in judgm t of law never dies I 110 ...incorporeal hereditaments which savour of the realty. I 121

    A grant of a manor to be constructed to be a tenure for life

    I 125

    An estate... after possibility of issue extinct... must be created by the act of God.

    I 125

    A possibility of issue is always supposed to exist ... tho' the donces be ... on hundred years old. I 150 King can never neglect any thing I 150 The law presumes no wrong in any man

    I 174

    A perpetuity... the law abhors

    175

    II 177

    Wherever a greater estate and a less coincide & must in one & the same person... the less is immediately uninhabitated; or... is said to be merged; that is, sunk or drowned in the greater II 177 The King and the corporation can never die II 199

    [Of an estate] one man may have the possession, another the right of possession & a third the right of property

    II 199

    Right of possession... & right of property... a double right

    II 210

    Natural reason that... possessions of parents should go... to their children

    II 211 [After] the present possessor ... land by the law of nature would again become common. II 213 According to Bracton states shall never ascend because it is contrary to the laws of gravitation.
  • Title: [15 May 1807 + + 19 (11) Letter]
    Description: 15 May 1807

    + + 19 (11)

    Letter V

    I. Plan

    But supposing, what is so natural, all these supposed improvements, with their several justificative reasons, to be put by, or turned aside from in a mass - supposing the high personages on whom it depends, no less peremptory in the rejection of all new functions than in the maintenance of a fragment or a shadow, of the old - (for more than a fragment or a shadow is physically impossible) - supposing Custom, as usual, to be taken to breed rules from, instead of Reason, which Lord Bacon, with so little effect, has so long been recommending as the better breeder - another consideration, which I would beg him to submitt, is - that, though the efficacy of the learned Reformer's plan were much greater than I should expect to find it as to the lessening the amount of the draughts made on the time of the House on the score of the Appeals from Scotland, - and though the price paid by our brethren on that side of the Tweed in the shape of delay, vexation and expence endured at home, for their liberation from such part of the same burthen as is expected this to be cleared away in the House of Lords even less than I should expect to find it - still the time consumed by Appeals, from that one of the three kingdoms, is but a part of the time expended by the House upon its appellate judicature: other Appeals, to an amount not spoken of, and probably destined to encrease, having hitherto been kept out of sight by the disguise of another name: and that, upon the whole, were the remedy to operate to the whole of the extent expected or professed to be expected, it would still fall short of covering the disease:- that in a word the distemper is incapable of being reached in its root by any other remedy, than that which consists in applying to the second branch of the supreme judicature that familiar rule, which with so happy a success has already been applied to the first - viz. qui facit per alium, facit per se. I speak here - not of the nominal and fictitious instruments of the King's will - but irremoveable Judges: but of the ephemeral, and thence (whensoever it so pleases him) the actual instruments of his will - his delegates - Lord's Delegates:- in this appellative Your Lordship sees at once not only the name but in some measure the essential character of an efficient tribunal, by which the functions and more than the functions the discharge of which has been found so compleatly impracticable to the House itself may be discharged with ease:- Lords Delegates, an offspring of the House, animated at all times by whatsoever portion of its own spirit, the House may think fit to put into it.