date

8 Oct r 1809 Parl y Reform
8 Oct r 1809

Parl y Reform

1 Necessity

Ch. Occasional inadequate

§.1. Changes how produced

2

2

Intervention better than nothing at all. Blackst. IV. C.11. p.147

Interventions[?] were constantly recurring[?]: then[?] not.

The sort of faculty which in this respect they possess is certainly better than none

at all: since on the part of the body any the least facility for giving expression to

the sentiments of the people is better than none at all. But that, in the character

of a security /preservative/ against misrule or so much as in the character of a

security against arbitrary power, this faculty of occasional interposition is far

from being /approaching to the nature of/ an equivalent to a regularly-recurring

interposition on the part of the same authority, will /is a proposition /are truths/

that will I trust/ be the more clearly perceptible the more closely the subject is

considered.

It is nothing like a sufficient /altogether insufficient and inefficient in the

character of a/ security against habitual misrule /it will be seen to be altogether

insufficient and even inefficient/: and being so, it would not be enough, though it

were sufficient in the character of a security against a /the/ compleat overthrow of

the constitution by arbitrary power: which it will also be seen not to be.

Three or four times in a century this /such/ interposition or the apprehension of it

may have the effect of producing a change in administration: which change may be for

the better or the worse.

But for the sake of clear conceptions let us admitt /it be admitted/ that a change

of this sort will by this cause be produced ten times in the course of a century:

upon an average once in every ten years: and that upon each occasion an

administration which though, as proved by its continuance in office, acceptable to

the King, will have been justly odious /odious, and justly so/ to the people, will

have given place to another administration either popular or less unpopular.
Similar Items
  • Title: [8 Oct r 1809 + Parl y Reform]
    Description: 8 Oct r 1809 +

    Parl y Reform

    1 […?]

    Ch. Occasional inadequate[?]

    Ch. 16. The casual interposition of the people is not sufficient.

    §. 1. Sole and rare effect—change of administration—how produced.

    On the part of the people at large interposition in regard to the conduct of public

    affairs, may (it has been observed) and actually does, occasionally take place. This

    /In this faculty of occasional/ interposition some have seen or pretended to see at

    the same time a sufficient counterbalance to the influence of the King in and over

    the House of Commons, a sufficient security against arbitrary power, a conclusive

    evidence that the people possess /are in the actual possession and exercise an

    efficient/ influence over the conduct of public affairs: which influence it is

    contended is as much as they ought to have—in other words, as much as it is for their

    own advantage that they should have.
  • Title: [8 Oct r 1809 + §.2 Parl y Reform]
    Description: 8 Oct r 1809 + §.2

    Parl y Reform

    B. I. Necessity

    Ch. Occasional inadequate

    §.2. Changes, inadequate

    6

    1

    §.2. Changes of administration are inadequate to the purpose

    Thus it is that the habitual tide of despotism is subject to be stemmed for the

    moment by occasional storms. But of this sort of security against misrule what is the

    use or value?

    For ten years together /the whole of these ten years/ the course of despotism and of

    that misrule which is the consequence of despotism—of unchecked power—has gone on

    without ceasing—all this time the business has been conducted /carried on/ by

    unfit—by comparatively if not compleatly and absolutely unfit—hands Bad measures in

    any numbers may have been carried into effect: good measures in any numbers remained

    unthought of, or if thought of and brought upon the carpet, rejected or in some other

    way frustrated.

    Worn out or blunted /and become unfit for use/ the old set of instruments are now

    discarded /thrown by/. But the people in what respect are they gainers? Then hand—the

    invisible irresponsible, the uncontrouled and uncontroulable hand that worked with

    the old instruments, the same hand and with the same power goes to work with the new.

    To the old set of servants succeeds a new one: but the new servants are still in the

    same set of dependence as the old ones were: what they succeed to is—not power—not

    independence as against the King not dependence on the people but dependence on the

    arbitrary will of the Monarch to the same yoke as that which kept pressing on the

    necks of their predecessors. At so easy a price as that of dismissing an old set of

    servants as soon as he is tired of them, the King rubs off his old scores: the tablet

    washed clean, and now he is at full liberty to commence a new one. The people have

    got that which is termed satisfaction: and which is all the satisfaction that in this

    state of things they can have: the satisfaction of seeing the same sort of work going

    on under /performed by/ a different set of hands. Hampshire can no longer be defended

    in Hanover by M r Pitt or M r Addington: but it

    may be, and is defended if not with equal success with at least equal energy by Lord

    Grenville and M r Fox.
  • Title: [9 Oct r 1809 + §.3 Parl y Reform]
    Description: 9 Oct r 1809 + §.3

    Parl y Reform

    2 o

    B. I. Necessity

    Ch. Occasional inadequate

    §.3. Burke advocates occasional

    1

    §.3. Occasional, to the exclusion of constant, interposition pleased for

    /advocated/ by Burke

    Occasional interposition—(it must be confessed)—‘ interposition’ indeed, but that not more nor other than occasional—was what was

    desired and pleaded for, on the part of the people by Edmund Burke.

    ‘Indeed’ (says he +) ‘in the situation in which we stand, with an

    immense revenue, an enormous debt, mighty establishments, Government itself a great

    banker and a great merchant, I see no other way for the preservation of a decent

    attention to public interest in the Representatives, but the

    interposition of the body of the people itself’ (the words italicized here

    are italicized in the original) ‘of the body of the people itself—Yes—but when?

    {Periodically and regularly and} at {stated and} pre-appointed and foreknown

    times?—No: but on some very particular occasion or occasions, when the purpose of a

    very particular and meritorious connection of Noble Lords and Gentlemen may be

    answered by it, things being at that pitch that for giving the country the benefit of

    their services, nothing less, nothing else will serve—‘whenever’ (continues he) ‘it

    shall appear, by some flagrant and notorious act, by some capital

    innovation, that these Representatives are going to over-leap

    the fences of the law, and to introduce an arbitrary power’;—a state /juncture/ of

    things the arrival and continued existence of which the ninety-nine preceding pages

    had been employed to prove.

    + Thoughts on the causes of the present discontents. p. 100.