date

1819 Jan. y 4 Parl. Reform Bill
1819 Jan. y 4

Parl. Reform Bill

Dialogues

Preliminary View

56

Conclusion

Reformist. May I not now indulge some hope of your approbation for my plan?

Anti-Reformist. I will consider of it.

Reformist. This is all I ask, and as much as for the present I can expect.

Anti-Reformist. Thus much I am prepared already to say to you, that if in any part

of it there be any gross absurdity, it is more than I have been able to discern[?].

As to your motives ...

Reformist. Oh, let us not talk /think/ of motives. Ascribe to the author what

motives you please /Man shall be what you please/, the work /plan/ will be neither

the better nor the worse.

Think your objections over again – look at them one by one – one and all you will

find them one and all the result – not of thought, but of want of thought. Vague

generalities such as their apt denominations – such their common character: current

language, commonly received and never[?] examined conceptions – such is their

source.
Similar Items
  • Title: [1819 Jan. y 12 Parl. Reform Bill]
    Description: 1819 Jan. y 12

    Parl. Reform Bill

    Preliminary View

    Evils & Remedies

    Remedies

    Miselection

    Electors

    Qualifications

    3 Scholarship

    10

    51

    Anti Reformist. Ah now – here are you running riot again. You have forgot your list

    of qualifications. Are you come to the end of them?

    Refromist. Not quite: there remains one more. With your leave to save words, I will

    call it in one word Scholarship.

    Anti-Reformist. Scholarship, quotha? and so your voters are to be all Scholars: and

    none but such as are Scholars are to have votes. Well – one comfort is – that the

    multitude which I confess I have always been so much afraid of will be somewhat

    thinned.

    Reformist. Not so much as you seem to imagine. All the scholarship I require is

    contained in a man’s being able to read the bible in his mother tongue, and to trace

    out in any legible manner the small number of characters of which his name is

    composed.

    Anti-Reformist. And of those who do not /would not otherwise/ possess it how many do

    you expect and in your expectation put themselves in possession of this qualification

    /it/. How many are there that would find means? how many are there that would find

    motives?

    Reformist. As for what regards means, the point /matter/ has been pretty well

    settled already: settled by an experiment made in a scale of such extent, and under

    such disadvantages, as suffices already to throw the /all/ idea of difficulty out of

    the case.

    Anti-Reformist. What is this you are talking of ? /have in view?/ {you are so

    sanguine about? What new and curious invention have you got here?}
  • Title: [1819 Jan. y 10 Parl. Reform Bill]
    Description: 1819 Jan. y 10

    Parl. Reform Bill

    Preliminary View

    Evils & Remedies

    II. Remedies

    Miselection

    II. through transgressions of law

    1

    37

    Leget ut Clericus.[?]

    Anti-Reformist. Well now, suppose them all effective and adequate these remedies of

    yours for the prevention of Miselection through unfitness on the part of that law

    itself in that part of the law by which the qualification of proposed Members and

    Electors are respectively appointed /determined/ prescribed, let us now see what

    provision you make One cause of Miselection shall remain, I mean the misexecution or

    non-execution of the determinations /appointments/ so made. Under the provisions so

    made according to the plan chalked out by you, in the District of Freeborough,

    Francis Freeman is the proposed Member that ought to have been returned But by mal

    practice in some shape or other say force or fraud, not he but William Wrongham has

    been returned. What remedies does your plan provide against Miselection from such a

    cause?

    Reformist. The same that it provides against Non-election and Null Election. Such is

    the connection All those Election evils, they are, all of them, liable to be produced

    by the same set of causes, all of them capable of being prevented /obviated/ by the

    same remedies. Force, fraud, accident – to /under/ one or other of these heads may

    all the disastrous causes in question be found referable /reducible/. {Simplicity of

    arrangement despatch.} Care taken for the Exclusion of motives to delinquency – for

    the exclusion of the means of delinquency, for the notoriety of all the relevant

    facts – in this short list you have /these words will conduct you to/ the

    remedies
  • Title: [1819 Jan y Parl. Reform Bill]
    Description: 1819 Jan y

    Parl. Reform Bill

    Dialogue

    Preliminary View

    Corruptibility

    Annuality

    11

    2

    53

    {34}

    Anti-Reformist continued. But /let then/ suppose them thus bought – how, after all

    your pains to secure the most apt Election what after all have you but Miselection.

    For being thus corrupt after they are bought, what they were before they were bought

    is matter of indifference.

    Reformist. Monarch ready to buy. Representatives ready to be bought. Very well.

    Readiness of this sort, readiness, on both sides, as perfect as you please. But here

    then, comes in our remedy, annuality of election on the part of the whole body of

    Electors speedy removal /cutting off/ of the corrupt and offending number.

    Anti-Reformist. Oh yes: when the mischief is done, then are you ready with your

    preventive remedy. When the needless millions have been voted, and the act passed,

    then are you ready to turn out those by whom they have been voted. Then, in come

    another set, who being bought, vote and are turned out: and so things go on after

    your reform as according to you they do now without it.

    Reformist. {Smart enough: but rather too lively.}