JB_161a.Spencers.xml

Title: [[Around folios 1 to 19] Defence of]

Description: [Around folios 1 to 19]

Defence of Economy - II. ag t I. Burke

Ch. 4

Concerning party men and their principles.

[Around folios 1 to 13]

Sextus for B.

[Around folios 20 to 41]

Ch. 9. Paul’s Style. I. Argument.

§. 1. For judging of aptitude of style in antient discourses the existing state of

things is no improper object of reference. What would be unapt now was unapt then.

§. 2. Forms of inaptitude in style - Forms of intellectual weakness in argumentation: 1.

Obscurity; - in its highest degree, Nonsensicalness: 2 Irrelevancy in argumentation; 3.

Irrelevancy in reference - demonstration ex auctoritate ill conducted; 4. Desultoriness

§. 3. By obscurity, inspiration may be disproved: and in Paul’s case, is.

§. 4. Nonsense - its abundance in Paul’s discourses.

§. 5. Paul’s demonstrations ex auctoritate - their irrelevancy.

[verso]

Ch. 8 2 o

Paul’s Style.

[Around folios 42 to 57]

Ch. 6 I. Argument

Paul’s Style

§. Different forms of Nonsense observable in the discourses of S t

Paul

[Around folios 58 to 68]

I. Argument

2 1

Style and Character

[Around folios 69 to 85]

I. Argument

Ch

Paul’s Character

§. 1. All things to all men.

§. 2. Falsified predictions.

[Around folios 86 to 128]

I. Argument

Ch. 6

Of Quasi-Miracles, Visions, Quasi-Visions and Trances.

[Around folios 133 to 140]

I. Argument.

Ch. 7

Natural causes of Paul’s Success.

§. 1. Energy - how operating as a pledge of security it produces persuasion in favour of

any discourse /doctrine/ howsoever absurd.

§. 2. Nonsense - its advantage - it is refutation proof.

§. 3. The success of a religion is no proof of its verity.

§. 4. The more absurd a religion, the stronger the attachment to it.

[Full folio wrapper around folios 141 to 214]

[front cover]

III Style.

Character.

III. Doctrine

(exclusive of Asceticism.

[spine]

1818.

Not Paul.

Style

Character

and

Doctrine

not

concerning

Asceticism.

[Around folios 141 to 162]

III. Doctrine

Ch

Paul’s Doctrines

§. 1. Plan of this Chapter

§. 2. Paul’s doctrine avowedly independent of that delivered to us as Jesus’s

§. 2. Real object and design of Paul’s doctrines - his temporal advancement.

§. 3. Doctrines more immediately subservient to that end 1. Magnification of faith: viz

in the sense inculcated by him.

§. 4. — 2. Depreciation of works: viz. in that Mosaic sense in which they were rivals to

faith as above in the struggle for salvation

§. 5. Doctrines less immediately and forcibly subservient: 1. Mysticism. 2. Asceticism

[Around folios 163 to 172]

Not Paul

III. Doctrine

§ Mysticism on the commemoration of the death of Jesus.

[verso]

Not Paul

Ch.

Conclusion.

[Around folios 173 to 186]

III. Doctrine.

Ch. III. Faith - its alledged necessity to salvation - alledged duty of possessing it.

[Around folios 187 to 199]

Ch. 9.

Paul’s Doctrine Ch. or §. Causes of Paul’s asceticism

§. 1. Cause I. In all other pursuits he beheld rivals to that he

preached: the greater the pleasure, the more formidable the rivalry

§. 2. II Cause II. Notion he found prevalent - heaven not to be purchased but by

sacrifices: the greater the sacrifice, the surer the purchase.

§. 3. Paul’s arguments in support of asceticism - their absurdity.

§. 4. By his anxiety to obtain female married converts, Paul is led into repugnancy to

Jesus

[Around folio 208]

III. Doctrine.

excepting Asceticism.

[Around folios 209 to 211]

Not Paul III Doctrine

§. 1. Faith - Paul’s meaning by it. Faith in him, or to his use

[Around folios 212 to 214]

III. Doctrine.

Ch. 10

Ch. 10 Mischievous Doctrines, deduced from Paul but unwarrantably

JB_139_103.xml

Title: [[Some marginal summary paras. on this folio]

Description: [Some marginal summary paras. on this folio. This transcript is the material which is not marginal summary paras.]

1818 Feb y 9

Not Paul

 22 Jan y 1819

Compare the matter of this Sheet with that of Ch | |

I. He set up his own authority against that of the Apostles collectively

II. and severally

III. Never for his support did he refer to their authority

IV. Never on the grounds of any censure pronounced by him did he include disregard shewn to their authority

JB_139_057.xml

Title: [[Some marginal summary paras. on this folio]

Description: [Some marginal summary paras. on this folio. This transcript is the material which is not marginal summary paras.]

1817 Sept. 14

Not Paul

§. 1. Paul’s doctrines the result of his worldly scheme: 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25

§. 2 Faith in him his primum mobile. 1. 2. 3. 4 5. 6. 26. 31.

§. 3. Faith, how far conducive to true religion 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 32

- good, only in so far as well as applied: in the abstract, conducive to false religion.  Add as well as to folly and improbity.

§. 4 Of the faith inculcated by Paul, verbal object Jesus’s doctrines: real, his own. 13. 40. 41.

§. 5 God’s attributes - which of them it suited his purpose to hold up particularly to view. 14

§. 5. Observances - what it suited his purpose most strenuously to inculcate. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. See Ch | | Paul’s asceticism causes of it.

§. 7. Paul’s inducements for preaching in Jesus’s name, and not in his own 27. 28. 29. 30.

§. 8. Paul’s inducements depretiating works: viz. Jewish works 33. 40.

§. 9. The works depretiated by him were Jewish works only not moral ones. 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40