6 April 1805

Evidence

Securities

Ch. Procedure Technical

''. Allegation is Evidence

So far as /concerns/ matter of fact is concerned whatever is or can be said by or on behalf of any party litigant, whether as of his own knowledge, or not as of his own knowledge, is still in its nature a mass or lot of evidence: if as of his own knowledge the more ordinary kind of evidence immediate evidence: if not as of his own knowledge, it is still evidence, though belonging to the head of makeshift, say for example Hearsay evidence.

The Plf is a shopkeeper. The defendant he says had goods without paying for them to the value of twenty days labour out of his ship: it is for this that he demands payment It was by the Plff above no other person knowing any thing about the matter that the goods were delivered, and so the Plff says in his allegation says, the evidence thus delivered by the Plff is immediate evidence: if it was by several of the Plff's, the plaintiff not professing to know any thing about the matter but from the report of the servant, the evidence given by the Plff in and by his allegation /the demand[?], whereby he alleges the existence/ of the cause of action, the evidence thus delivered by him is of the nature of makeshift - of Hearsay evidence.

in this case what he can not say and say with truth is that he knows the existence of the fact /is known to him/ of his own knowledge: - what he can say, and mendacity apart can say with truth, is - that the existence of the fact though not known by him of his own knowledge, is believed. If not believing it, he says that he believes it, if without oath, he is a liar: if under oath, a perjurer.