24 May 1804

B,

Evidence

2.

Forthcomingness

Ch. Extraction

§.2. Personal[?]. Party's

§ 2. Extraction of personal evidence - Party's defendant's evidence.

In the case of personal evidence - in that case centers all the difficulty: in this case it is but true that the legislator will find, be his sagacity what it may, a most perplexing choice of difficulties.

By One fundamental division /distinction/, the distinction between the evidence of a party, and the evidence of an extraneous witness, a considerable light will be thrown upon the subject in the first instance, and hence part of the difficulty will be seen[?] to be cleared away.

First let it be the evidence of the defendant, and the cause a non-penal one - Examine him - will he not speak? no matter: let him lose his cause. Reasons already given under another head. + By his refusal to answer he escapes furnishing direct evidence: but by the same negative act, actually he furnishes evidence: evidence which though but circumstantial, is as condusive as any direct evidence would be in the same case. In the case of the plaintiff, there is as little difficulty, or rather, if possible, still less: the falsity of the allegations on which his claim is founded is virtually acknowledged by himself.

(a) Bill taken per[?] confess.

+ B. Circumstantial

Ch. Non-re