Evidence

23 July 1805

Introd.

Ch. Perversion

2. Second mode of perversion. In this second mode the language perverted by the man of law is the language that issues out of his own lips. He says one thing, he means a different thing. The meaning annexed to these words by himself he keeps to himself: he keeps it to himself, lest the suitor, understanding what] His plan is, that the suitor, in pretence of disobedience or non-compliance with rules shall, to the profit of the Judge and his confederates, be punished or otherwise vexed. To give the appearance of a warrant for the punishment, the first /one/ thing necessary /needful/ is to generate the offence. For this purpose it is that the Judge annexes in secret a false meaning to his own words. He commands the suitor to do /perform/ a certain act: the act so commanded to the suitor is performed and /whereupon/ the suitor is punished or otherwise vexed. Punished? and for what? - for not having performed another act that never was commanded. The act for the non-performance of which the suitor is then punished is an act which was never communicated to him: an act which it was the case of the Judge should not be communicated to him. The meaning of the Judge of the Judge was to be believed, was that the act for the one performance of which the suitor is punished by him should have been performed by him. But had this meaning been communicated to the suitor the acts in question might have been performed by him; whereby the plan for /of/ punishing him as for the one performance of it would have been disappointed. Thus pretended insanity - it was therefore necessary should be kept a secret from the suitor; and to keep this secret, inexpedient than which willing could be more effectual was employed; a set of words are employed, which according to the meaning annexed to them by all mankind (men of [...?] excepted) signified quite a different sort of act, and act such as would not to any body have presented the idea of the act in question, for the non-performance of which the suitor is punished or otherwise vexed and at any rate plundered.