1 May 1808

J.B. to H of Commons

I. Reason for the Work

English pleading inapplicable to Sotland

II. Defence

23. I. Of the four species of satisfaction correspondent to so many species of wrong, and capable, as above, of being taken for the subject or objects of so many sorts of demands, the two first are possessions of an individual thing, moveable in the first case or immoveable in the second. It is by the species of action called an action of trover, that notice of the demand made in the first instance is conveyed: it is by the species of action called an action of ejectment, that the demand made in the other instance is notified.

To either these demands the sort of defence most usually made is notified by the same expression Not Guilty: more at length, I am not guilty of the act charged upon me.

24. But in neither of these instances is any thing of Guilt so much as imputed to the defendant. In the case of the action of trover, what the plaintiff says to the defendant is - there is a something of mine which you having found, have converted to your own use.

In the case of the action of ejectment brought for the obtainment, for example, of ten acres situated on[?] such[?], what the plaintiff says of the defendant is, a person, real or imaginary, has turned an imaginary person out of a hundred acres situated in that same place.

In both these cases if what the plaintiff has been saying be false, there exists not on the defendant's part any thing that can justly bear the name of guilt: but as little is there any guilt on the defendant's part even admitting what is said on the Plaintiff's part is true.