15 Aug 1815

Jug. True

Miracles

Conditions of Credibility

Best evidence never given

2

On the occasions in question what then shall we say of an Almighty God in the character of the supposed author and prime mover of the acts in question for the purpose of their serving in character of evidence to satisfy men of the authenticity of a system of precepts delivered by himself or in persuance of orders given by himself? To which of his causes shall the inability or unwillingness be ascribed—Was he unable? where was his omnipotence. Was he unwilling? where was his wisdom his benevolence his justice?

Oh but it is not for us to attempt to penetrate into the [decree] of providence. Reasons he had most sufficient ones: and then came invectives reprobating the presumption and the like.

Oh yes if such was really his conduct no doubt need be made of its rectitude. But the question is, was it really his conduct? and from MS alt. illegible. the deficiency in respect of rectitude—from this course it is that the negative is inferred.

Such is the mode of reasoning: What in every occasion is required is that the very thing in dispute be taken for granted: and thereupon it is that the advocate of the incredible triumph rides triumphant and proves whatever it is that he has to prove.